Developers jumped through hoops Thursday night as the Newhall County Water Board began to wield its new and controversial water-availability resolution.
The board approved two water contracts after a developer agreed to yet-undetermined conditions; substituted a ?will-serve? letter for a contract in another case; and tabled an agreement at the request of the property owner.
Three other contracts of the seven that came before the board Thursday night were approved as proposed. But the developer for one will be asked to agree to conditions set at a Feb. 23 workshop.
Developer Dale Donohoe said Friday that he would cooperate.
Despite several assurances from President Lynne Plambeck that the board didn?t want to set back developers financially, many expressed frustration or dismay over the situation.
?If we don?t get a signed contract tonight, our investors will cancel on us,? said Lance Williams of MOBE Development Inc. ?What they want is a level of comfort that we can get water for the project.?
?(An agreement) is the best assurance we have,? said Williams, who had two agreements for Castaic developments on the board?s agenda Thursday night.
But the board balked at granting his requests, noting that his plans for 21 detached condominiums on one property and 18 on another had not yet gone through the county approval process.
Williams argued that the Castaic Town Council had approved both unanimously, but Plambeck said that agency is strictly advisory.
?I don?t think we can give you an agreement if the county hasn?t even approved,? Plambeck told Williams.
?We can give an agreement at any time,? responded Ken Peterson, general manager for the district.
?This leaves the door open for anyone who comes in tomorrow for an agreement,? said Director Maria Gutzeit.
Although the resolution passed Jan. 29 included a 90-day ?stay,? Plambeck and Gutzeit both expressed concern that the board would be flooded with last-minute requests for contracts if it didn?t begin imposing some restricted-water-availability standards immediately.
?I don?t want everybody coming in for an agreement before they?ve even broken ground just to get in (before deadline),? Gutzeit said.
?I don?t have any problem with going to the workshop, trying different things,? pleaded Williams, who recently received plaudits from city planning commissioners for high-quality ?infill? developments ? those on relatively small properties surrounded by prior development.
He suggested the board ?condition us to come to workshops and agree to conditions? set during those workshops as long as it issued a contract immediately.
The board voted to sign a contract with a memorandum of understanding that Williams would abide by agreements to be determined in a workshop or workshops.
The meeting was the district?s first since, on a 3-2 vote, the board passed a resolution challenging water-availability figures in the Urban Water Management Plan. That plan, embraced by other Santa Clarita Valley water agencies, is used to determine water supplies for future development. Newhall County?s resolution said significantly less water is available than the plan claims.
The water district, the valley?s oldest, serves most of Newhall and Castaic, much of Canyon Country, and a section of Saugus.
As the first proposed agreement on the agenda, Donohoe?s commercial development on The Old Road and Sloan Canyon Road in Castaic received approval Thursday after he informed directors his loan was ready to fund, awaiting only their approval.
?I cannot stress enough (that) bankers ... are pessimists by nature,? he said, echoing other developers? concerns that the board?s resolution was giving financiers cold feet.
?No one?s going to commit a million dollars on a ?maybe,?? Donohoe said Friday. ?That?s an awfully big ?if.??
After Donohoe?s agreement request, the board substituted a ?will-serve? letter with its resolution attached for the signed agreement sought by a developer who didn?t turn out for the meeting. ?Will-serve? letters are said to guarantee that water will be supplied, but Williams noted that they have become more and more conditional over the years.
A single-family home in Newhall received easy approval, with Plambeck saying such should be exempt from restrictions. Dale Ryan?s agreement for water service in two retail buildings at 24723 San Fernando Road also received approval, but not before he was questioned about water-conserving measures.
Ryan, like Donohoe, pointed out that he couldn?t change plans that were already approved.
?I think one of the things the board needs to understand is that you can?t go back and condition pre-approved projects,? he said.
?I thought it was the status quo for 90 days while you work out the implementation (of the resolution),? he added.
Earlier, Director Joan Dunn had raised the question of whether the ?stay of implementation? passed as part of the resolution should mean business as usual for the board until the 90 days are up.
Board attorney Tom Bunn said the resolution could be interpreted in that way, but Plambeck and Gutzeit rejected the idea and it was not introduced as a motion.
The last agreement to go before the board Thursday was for a 37-unit condominium complex in southern Castaic proposed by Forum Engineering and Construction. Forum CEO Moshe Tzemach and his consultant, Ron Druschen, withdrew their request when the board indicated it would not sign the contract.
Tzemach and Druschen said the project received a ?will-serve? letter 11 years ago and was approved in the mid-90s.
?Why is it that you can?t wait for the (resolution?s) implementation?? Plambeck asked the men. She said the county ought to require re-review for such old projects.
At one point during the discussion, Bunn remarked, ?Where the board draws the line, I kind of got the sense that it was for entitled projects.?
At that point Gutzeit said the board should go back to Donohoe and ask him to agree to the workshop conditions.
Director Barbara Dore argued that the case should be approved immediately under the grace period provided by the stay, but her fellow directors did not support her. She suggested a conditional agreement, but Tzemach and Druschen still demurred.
?I?m hopeful and optimistic that during these 90 days ... there will be communication back and forth,? Druschen said. ?I just don?t see a way that we can agree to something when we don?t know what we?re agreeing to.?
When board members pointed out that Williams had done so, Druschen responded, ?Every businessman has to take his chance.?
On Wednesday night, College of the Canyons trustees joined a long line of local governing bodies by unanimously condemning Newhall County?s resolution, saying it could hamper the district?s efforts to locate a second campus in Canyon Country.
Plambeck has said repeatedly that schools will not be affected by the resolution.
Directors set a workshop for Monday, Feb. 23, at 6:30 p.m. so smaller-project developers could help the board decide what conditions they must meet for future projects. Discussion Thursday indicated water-conservation measures will likely be part of the conditions.
Plambeck said she wants to meet with smaller developers to try to usher their projects through before big developments come before the board.
