The owner of the Soledad Canyon Metrolink property accused the Santa Clarita City Council of acting “capricious” when it voted 4-0 to take a surface easement by eminent domain Wednesday.
Gary Brown, director of development for the Phoenix-based Remediation Financial Inc., said the city’s offer to buy the 6-acre site for $1,000 to keep the Metrolink station open is absurd. Eminent domain is a process that allows public agencies to purchase property to increase public benefits.
“This is a capricious use of the city’s condemnation powers” Brown said. “This is setting a dangerous precedent.”
RFI and its subsidiaries, Bermite Recovery LLC and Santa Clarita LLC, own the Metrolink property and Porta Bella property, respectively.
The root of Brown’s arguments centers around the price tag the city put on the land.
“I think any citizen in Santa Clarita who was offered $1,000 for six acres of property would be left wondering if they left off some zeros there,” Brown said.
The 996-acre Porta Bella project is slated for 2,911 homes, an elementary school, commercial center and industrial park once the groundwater and soil are purged of a handful of contaminants, including ammonium perchlorate, and unexploded ordnance. Perchlorate was detected in water wells on the station property, and the state is currently devising plans to test the soil under the paved parking lot.
In a heated letter addressed to Interim City Manager Ken Pulskamp, an RFI attorney said the city’s offer was, “based upon a presumptively and fundamentally flawed rationale.”
City Attorney Carl Newton disagreed.
Newton said the 1996 agreement inked between the city and Porta Bella developer Santa Clarita LLC calls for the station land to be handed over to the city or should the city purchase property, it would be fully reimbursed after the project’s first phased was approved.
“(The land) has a nominal value,” Newton said.
Brown said the land is worth millions more than the city’s offer and said in the same agreement the property is valued at $2.5 million.
Newton said the council was exercising its eminent domain rights clearly stated in the state’s constitution.
That doesn’t matter to Brown, who said the company wasn’t going to accept the city’s offer.
“The city has said cleaning up the (Porta Bella) site is its No. 1 goal, and look at what they are doing,” he added. “The city has taken a position in which the end justifies the means. They have now stooped to any means possible to get (the Metrolink property) at the lowest possible price.”
City Planning Director Jeff Lambert said maintaining an operational Soledad Metrolink station is key to the city’s transportation system.
“We can’t afford to have that station closed,” Lambert said.
RFI tried to close the station last year after the city’s year-to-year lease expired. The city was renting the land per the 1996 agreement for $1 per year.
The city was successful in obtaining an injunction against the company.
Metrolink spokeswoman Sharon Gavin said earlier this week that the agency has pushed the city into purchasing the property.
Gavin said that if the city didn’t pursue eminent domain proceedings, the agency would then bill the city for legal expenses. She said the agency was under the assumption the city owned the station, which was built in 1993.
Newton said he will file papers in a county superior court today. It is not known when there will be a hearing about the case.
