The Sheriff?s Department filed a motion to dismiss a federal civil rights lawsuit, which was refiled against Sheriff Leroy D. Baca and the county of Los Angeles, that accused the department of failing to enforce court orders that dealt with child custody matters.
The department wants the case dismissed on grounds that the plaintiffs, Michael Riportella and Michele Lansing, failed to prove their Fourteenth Amendment rights were violated and that the case should be dismissed as moot since any ?threat of injury must be real and immediate, not conjectural or hypothetical,? attorneys for Baca said in court documents.
?The Fourteenth Amendment Due Process Clause does not generally require the state to protect the life, liberty and property of its citizens against invasion by private actors,? the motion states.
The issue first came to light when Riportella, a Valencia resident, obtained two separate Superior Court orders in September that granted him custody of his five children. Riportella attempted to take custody of his children from his ex-wife, Misty Riportella, who reportedly refused to return the children to their father. However, when Michael Riportella sought the assistance of deputies from the Santa Clarita Valley Sheriff?s Station, he alleged that the deputies, ?affirmatively refused to enforce this order, despite the fact that the order directed the Sheriff?s to take custody of the children,? court documents said.
Misty Riportella turned out to be a wanted fugitive in Montana. Lansing, the second plaintiff, later joined the lawsuit after alleging that the Sheriff?s Department did not assist her in obtaining physical custody of her children.
In court documents, Lansing, a Canyon Country resident, stated that she was awarded primary custody of her three minor children. Her ex-husband was awarded visitation on alternate weekends and at other specified times. Court documents revealed that on June 15, Lansing?s former husband ?took one of her children and refused to comply with the court?s order.? It was a refusal that lasted more than a month.
Lansing ?was deprived of custody of her minor children for 34 days and ultimately retrieved the child absent the assistance of defendants Los Angeles County and Sheriff Leroy Baca,? court documents state.
The Sheriff?s Department argued that the complaint essentially involved child custody matters and that the federal court lacks jurisdiction over domestic disputes.
U.S. District Judge Christina A. Snyder initially dismissed the lawsuit Jan. 7, without prejudice, meaning it can be refiled. Saugus attorney Anthony D. Zinnanti, who represents the two plaintiffs, refiled the claim Jan. 28.
q q q
After the motion to dismiss was filed Feb. 9, Zinnanti said he modified his case to allege discriminatory handling of family law litigants. Zinnanti is basing his arguments on a 2000 ruling by the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals which determined that the Sheriff?s Department is liable for its discriminatory handling of 1989, 911 call regarding domestic violence, which ultimately lead to the death of Maria Navarro.
According to court documents, Navarro, who was estranged from her husband, Raymond Navarro, received a call from her brother-in-law, warning her that Raymond was on his way to the house to kill her and others present. Maria Navarro then called 911 and told the dispatcher about the warning. The dispatcher responded, ?OK, well the only thing to do is just call us if he comes over there...I mean what can we do? We can?t have a unit sit there to wait and see if he comes over,? court documents said.
During that time, the Sheriff?s Department classified domestic violence 911 calls for assistance as non-emergency calls. Fifteen minutes after Navarro placed the call, her husband entered through the rear of the home in East Los Angeles, where a birthday party for Navarro was taking place, and killed Navarro and four other people, according to court documents. The Navarro family sued on an equal protection theory. In January 1989, Navarro obtained a restraining order against her husband, which expired that same month.
However, the dispatcher was not privy to the information at the time of the Navarro?s 911 call.
Zinnanti said this particular case is similar to the Riportella-Lansing incidents.
?I think (the Navarro case) is analogous to ours,? he said. ?The Sheriff?s Department?s discriminatory refusal to enforce court orders.?
Attorneys for the Sheriff?s Department and officials from the SCV Sheriff?s Station could not be reached for comment.
Zinnanti said particularly telling is the defendants argument that the lawsuit should be dismissed at moot.
?The Sheriff?s Department?s position is basically that it has no affirmative duty to protect one citizen against the acts of another,? he said. ?In Michele?s case, what the Sheriff?s Department essentially told her is that if she can grab the kid, physically take custody of the kid by herself, she can keep the kid,? Zinnanti said. ?This policy of self help by the Sheriff?s Department is a recipe for disaster.?
The next scheduled hearing date is scheduled for March 8.
