We’ve been down this road before, but this time, it seems like the road extends farther than it has in the past:
Should same-sex couples be allowed to get married?
Nearly four years ago, California voters approved Proposition 22, which stated that our state would only recognize marriages between a man and a woman.
The debate has simmered — sometimes edging close to the boiling point — on the state and national levels ever since then.
But never has the temperature gotten as hot as it has in the past couple of weeks, as San Francisco Mayor Gavin Newsom has decided to test the constitutionality of Prop. 22 by allowing same-sex marriages to be performed in San Francisco.
As of Friday, the count stood at more than 3,000 — and that doesn’t even take into account the fact that some other same-sex couples (including at least one I know of from right here in the Santa Clarita Valley) attempted to get married in San Francisco but were deterred by the long lines.
The simmer has escalated to a rolling boil.
Politicians on both the left and the right have been compelled to weigh in on the issue, and debate has been stirred to a higher pitch regarding possible federal legislation that would declare same-sex marriages invalid.
Everyone has an opinion on it. Even those who agree on the broader issue — and believe same-sex couples should be allowed to marry — don’t uniformly agree on the tactic employed by Newsom. Some observers say it may backfire and add steam to a federal gay marriage ban.
The Associated Press quoted U.S. Sen. Dianne Feinstein as saying, “The people of California voted on Proposition 22 and by an overwhelming majority passed a law which defines marriage as between a man and a woman. If the mayor believes that law is unconstitutional the place to go is the court.”
The senator — a San Francisco Democrat — has a point: Civil disobedience is sometimes a morally just way to bring attention to an unjust law that should be overturned. However, in the case of Mayor Newsom, he is a public official whose job it is to uphold the law, not flout it.
The court battle will, of course, happen. And we won’t soon be done talking about it.
As for me, I’ve been trying to formulate a strong opinion on this for some time now, and for the most part I have been ambivalent. I admit to having experienced knee-jerk feelings in the past — since every married person I’ve ever known has been part of a heterosexual union, the concept of same-sex marriage has simply seemed foreign, even in this era of greater openness about same-sex relationships.
But as time has passed, I’ve concluded that, at least for me, there is one key question in deciding whether to favor or oppose same-sex marriages:
If people of the same sex are allowed to get married, does that hurt anyone?
I don’t see how.
Tim Whyte is The Signal’s managing editor. His column appears Sundays, and his e-mail address is [email protected].
