The Winner's Circle
The Saugus and Hart swim teams don’t like each other.
Or so we’re told.
The respective coaches barely acknowledge one another and their respective swimmers secretly plot to fasten weights to each other’s ankles before each event.
Or so we’re led to believe.
People who insist an unfriendly rivalry exists between the Indians and the Centurions like to point to last season — and specifically some unorthodox decisions by Saugus coach Jim Klipfel — as proof.
Last year, Klipfel kept his girls’ times out of the press because he didn’t want Hart knowing how to counter his new-found strength. Last year’s crop of girls gave him his best shot at breaking Hart’s 21-year grip on the Foothill League and he wasn’t going to concede any advantage.
Much was made of Klipfel’s clandestine approach, but none of it came from the Hart camp. Parents weighed in, but parents always weigh in. Members of the media may have grumbled, but what do we know?
The Centurions edged the Indians in their meeting, so perhaps history proved Klipfel right. Call him paranoid if you want. But ask yourself, how many coaches allow opposing teams’ scouts to watch their teams practice?
In swimming, winning and losing usually comes down to strategy, and knowing how to best match up with the competition is the answer to all riddles. Learning the other team’s times is how you unlock that mystery.
Klipfel’s choice to withhold his girls’ times was pure strategy, that and maybe a bit of intimidation. But it had nothing to do with thumbing his nose at Hart.
The Foothill League swim season opens this week, and alongside it creeps the rumor about how much the opposing camps dislike each other.
Like any good rumor, it finds its roots is assumption and fallacy. And like any good rumor, it will not go away.
I call it a rumor because I was at COC last season when Saugus prevailed, and I didn’t see the hatred.
Sure, the Indians were disappointed, but I saw no malice. Yes, the Centurions were elated, but they did no taunting.
And the coaches? They talked and exchanged pleasantries at the scorer’s table, at least as much as you might expect under the circumstances.
I call it a rumor because I’ve been poolside this year and seen the swimmers — gasp — carrying on not just civil, but friendly conversation.
I finally asked Hart girls coach Gina McCarthy about the supposed rivalry last week after Saugus beat Louisville and Crespi at the new Santa Clarita Aquatic Center.
She was leaving her teams’ practice — Hart and Saugus now train in the same pool, sometimes side by side, believe it or not.
“Jim was my daughter’s first coach,” she said. “Half these kids grew up together. You can’t have animosity when you swim because it actually makes it harder. The kids don’t feel any of that.”
For his part, Klipfel himself seems weary of all the talk surrounding the two programs.
“It’s not us against them,” he said. “We’re all from this valley. We root for each other at CIF. I’m happy when they do well. I hope [Hart] gives us the best meet possible. It’s exciting when teams are competing. It makes this job a lot of fun.”
The truth is, high school swimming — at its highest levels — really isn’t comprised of high school swimmers. It’s populated by a bunch of club swimmers who don their high school colors on the side.
On Tuesday and Wednesday afternoons in the spring, they swim against each other, but at the club level, all bets — and all allegiances — are off. Many actually become teammates.
There’s not room for hatred there, sorry.
So hype the Saugus-Hart swim rivalry if you must. I’m the first to agree one does exist.
But call it anything but a friendly competition and you might as well jump into the pool with the rest of the swimmers because you’re already all wet.
Bob Dickson’s column appears every Sunday in The Signal. He can be reached at [email protected].
