California Highway Patrol officers marked the 34th anniversary Tuesday of a tragedy that changed the way the CHP and many other law-enforcement agencies deal with the public.
It was just before midnight on April 5, 1970, when CHP officers Walter Frago and Roger Gore, both 23, pulled a car off Interstate 5 at what is now Magic Mountain Parkway. The two were responding to a report that the car had been involved in a minor accident near Gorman, and that one of the two men inside had brandished a gun at the occupant of the other vehicle.
Backing up Frago and Gore were officers James Pence and George Alleyn, both 24. But their patrol car had not arrived yet when Frago and Gore stopped the suspects’ car in the parking lot of J’s Coffee Shop, where Marie Callender’s Restaurant now stands.
“Prior to that point, I think because of the (1965) L.A. riots, law enforcement was very concerned about their demeanor with the public,” CHP Officer Wendy Moore said Tuesday. “They were more public-relations oriented.”
“So they didn’t walk up with their guns drawn,” she said. “The first two ... actually walked up with their shotgun held upright.”
But the two men in the suspect vehicle, Jack Twinning and Bobby Augusta Davis, had an “arsenal of weapons,” Moore said.
The suspect on the passenger’s side of the vehicle opened fire, and within a minute and a half both officers were dead.
“The secondary unit came in right in the middle of a firefight,” Moore said.
Within another few minutes, all four officers lay dead or dying.
A Saugus resident, Gary Kness, tried to help and actually exchanged gunfire with the shooters, using the gun of one of the downed officers. But Kness was forced to flee through a drainage ditch as the last officer was slain.
Twinning and Davis fled, but Davis was later shot by the driver of a camper that he tried to commandeer.
Twinning holed up in the Pico Canyon home of Glenn Hoag, whom he took hostage. Twinning eventually released Hoag and apparently committed suicide as officers lobbed tear gas into the residence.
Before killing himself, Twinning, 35, held a phone conversation with Sheriff’s Lt. Paul Vasquez during which he calmly discussed suicide and remarked, “You can’t possibly have any, ah, compassion for me after those policemen went down the drain.”
Davis survived his wounds and is serving life behind bars at Pelican Bay State Prison in northern California.
The tragedy is the worst massacre in the history of the CHP, which is celebrating its 75th anniversary this year, Moore said.
“It dramatically changed the policies of law enforcement agencies nationwide,” she said.
For example, Moore said, “When we get some sort of a call that could possibly involve a weapon, it’s a higher-risk situation, and we handle it as such.
“We would get them out of the car one-by-one, standing behind cover.”
