Lifeguards who work at three county-run lakes, including Castaic, want to switch departments and become fire personnel, but Department of Parks and Recreation officials want them to stay put.
“It’s a matter of increasing public safety, making us better prepared to do our job,” said Derek Elleri, a senior lifeguard at Puddingstone Lake and president of the lake lifeguards’ union.
The U.S. Lifesaving Association “is very clear on the fact that lifeguards should lifeguard,” Elleri said. “You take them away from watching the water ... and you have more problems.”
He said proposals from Parks and Recreation officials have included placing lifeguards in charge of changing toilet paper in portable restrooms.
“Is that what we want our trained lifeguards doing, or should they be out watching the water?” he asked.
Sheila Ortega, spokeswoman for Parks and Recreation, said Director Tim Gallagher’s main concern “is in the way that the lifeguards currently are associated with our facilities. They pitch in and do general duties, they help us adjust the docks and with the necessary chlorination at the lakes.” They also help out with special events, she said.
“We have some concerns that if they were with fire, they may not want to do those types of functions,” Ortega said
That, in turn, could cost taxpayers extra money if the county had to hire additional staff.
An additional concern is that lifeguards would have two supervisors to report to — one from county fire and the Parks and Recreation supervisor, who would still be in charge of the overall park operation, Ortega said.
Lifeguards at county-run beaches have worked for the Fire Department for about 10 years, Elleri said. Lake lifeguards have sought the same status for about the same amount of time.
Supervisor Michael D. Antonovich proposed Tuesday that lake lifeguards be reassigned to the Fire Department, but supervisors voted “to further study the issue,” Antonovich Deputy Jennifer Plaidsted. The issue is expected to be brought up again during county budget deliberations.
Both Plaisted and Elleri said the proposal calls for no pay change for the lake lifeguards.
“We’re not looking for a change in pay. All our benefits and retirement plans (would be transferred to the Fire Department) across the board,” Elleri said.
He said ocean lifeguards receive superior training and are certified by the U.S. Lifesaving Association. Lake lifeguards have sought that certification for five or six years, without success, he said.
“It’s an uphill battle to get those trainings,” he said. “Every time we have advanced as an organization, we’ve been following what the ocean lifeguards have been doing.”
The county only has 15 permanent, full-time lake lifeguards left following recent staffing cuts, Elleri said. They earn about $50,000 to $55,000 a year.
Seasonal, part-time staff start at $14.58 an hour.
Full-time staff includes two lifeguards at Castaic Lake Recreation Area, eight at Puddingstone Lake in San Dimas and five at Santa Fe Dam Recreation Area in Irwindale, Elleri said.
