Convincing Mexican officials they should bow to American wishes and return the suspected killer of Deputy David March to Los Angeles County for trial may have gotten more complicated last week.
On Wednesday, Mexican President Vicente Fox scored a major victory in the court of world opinion. On a 14-1 vote, the International Court of Justice in The Hague ruled that nearly all Mexican citizens on death row in the United States had their rights trampled.
“Mexico has been proven right,” Fox gloated, “insofar as legal procedures were not respected in some trials in the United States that led to death sentences for our fellow citizens.”
Los Angeles County Supervisor Michael D. Antonovich was incredulous.
“For President Fox to insist on U.S. compliance in the name of justice is the height of hypocrisy, considering the Mexican government’s continued failure to extradite cop killers such as Chato Garcia, who killed Deputy David March,” Antonovich said Monday.
Armando “Chato” Garcia is wanted for the April 29, 2002, murder of Sheriff’s Deputy David March of Saugus. Garcia, a Mexican citizen, fled to his home state of Michoacan within 24 hours after the murder and has remained at large because Mexico will not extradite citizens who face capital punishment or life in prison in the United States.
Mexico’s policy enrages District Attorney Steve Cooley.
“(Mexico is dictating) to us a second system of justice for those who were clever enough, smart enough, resourceful enough or lucky enough to get to Mexico,” Cooley said recently. “What they should do is honor our laws, respect the fact that the murder occurred here, and let us prosecute (Garcia) for that crime and mete out the appropriate sentence under our laws.”
Instead, Mexico — which leads the tally of foreign nationals on death row in the United States at 55 out of 121, including an estimated 28 in California and 15 in Los Angeles County — has convinced the international community to indict our criminal justice system.
An unnamed Mexican diplomat said Mexico will take the next step to enforce U.S. compliance. Decisions of the World Court, the judicial wing of the United Nations, can be brought to the U.N. Security Council for “appropriate action” when countries don’t comply.
Will Fox send troops if the United States ignores a future U.N. Security Council resolution?
It’s not clear the federal government can compel courts in our 50 semi-autonomous states to comply, even if the U.S. State Department wanted them to.
Thankfully, the World Court didn’t go quite as far as Fox hoped it would.
Fox wanted to overturn the conviction and sentence of every Mexican death-row inmate, to remedy alleged breaches of Article 36 of the Vienna Convention on Consular Relations of April 24, 1963.
Among other things, the article gives foreign prisoners something akin to international Miranda rights. Prisoners must be advised “without delay” of their right to consular assistance, and the consulate must be allowed to visit the inmates and appoint lawyers.
The United States was found in violation of one or more clauses of Article 36 in 51 of the 52 cases that were before the court. (One was tossed out because the convict was a dual national.)
Rather than order freedom and retrial, as Fox wanted, the court decided the United States could “review and (reconsider) the convictions and sentences of the Mexican nationals” through the normal appeals process in the United States.
The lone dissenter among the 15 justices wasn’t the U.S. appointee to the court, Thomas Buergenthal. A George Washington University law professor and noted human rights advocate, Buergenthal sided with the majority.
Rather, it was the Venezuelan justice, Gonzalo Parra-Aranguren, who felt Mexico hadn’t adequately established the citizenship of the 51 convicts.
The ruling didn’t set a precedent for the United States. In 1998, Paraguay sued but dropped the case when its citizen was executed. In 1999, Germany won in court but lost at the gallows when U.S. officials ignored the order.
If California and the eight other states with Mexican death-row inmates thumb their noses at Fox and his World Court order, he may feel he has little incentive to cooperate in the David March matter.
The United States has until May 18 to figure out how to play its cards. That’s when the next Mexican death-row inmate dies.
Leon Worden is The Signal’s city editor.
