Equal they came and equal they went.
Saugus entered the bottom of the 11th at Bud Murray Field with a 6-4 lead while the glowing remains of daylight slipped into the dusk.
But two outs away from victory, an awkward hop off the lip of the infield grass changed everything and ultimately nothing changed. Then a double. Then they were back where they started. Officially fit it to be tied.
Tyler Fick’s two-out, two-strike single to left off Saugus ace Jason Pfau scored Matt Valaika from third to tie the game 6-6 when darkness won out Tuesday evening.
Hart and Saugus enter tied for second place in the Foothill League and left tied 6-6.
“It’s a tie. ... That’s not good,” Hart shortstop Matt Valaika said.
It was Valaika’s one-out double in the bottom of the 11th that scored Cole Valancius and brought Hart to within 6-5.
“Of course, it’s always scary when you have daylight dying,” Valaika said. “We knew we had to come up big and that was it.”
But it was Valancius who reached base on a kangaroo-hop single over the head of Saugus shortstop Steve Eaton. Valancius’ grounder caught the lip of the grass and sprung into left field with one out.
“It just takes one guy to get on base,” the Indians’ left fielder said.
After giving up the double to Valaika, Saugus reliever Stephen Grechowsky was spelled by Pfau, who had spent all afternoon in right field to that point. When the these two teams first met this season, in the league opener, Pfau one-hit the Indians.
The first batter the left-hander faced, Steve Susdorf, grounded out to short, allowing Valaika to advance to third.
With two outs, Fick, who had taken over the Indians’ pitching duties in the top of the 11th, stepped to the plate. One pitch before his game-tying single to left, the Saugus dugout erupted, thinking Pfau had struck out Fick looking. The umpire called ball, sending Saugus back into the dugout.
Fick slapped the next pitch into left, which kept Hart in second place at least until Friday when the two teams conclude the season series.
“This makes Friday all that much bigger,” Saugus’ Travis Babin said. “No one gets a lead. It’s going to be a battle.”
Hart (9-8-1, 4-2-1) never led during the 11-inning affair, but always remained within reach.
Trailing 3-0 in the bottom of the fifth, designated hitter Ben Edwards hit a two-run homer off Saugus starter Tommy Milone. Edwards homered in a pinch hitting role a week before against Canyon.
The Centurions (11-3-1, 4-2-1) enhanced their lead to 4-2 in the sixth when Hart reliever Steve Sanchez issued a walk to Saugus’ Ian Bridges with the bases loaded. Hart also walked in a run in the third and allowed another on a passed ball in the fifth.
But the Indians caught a break with one out in the bottom of the seventh.
Edwards hit a grounder to short and Eaton’s throw pulled Milone off the bag. Milone caught the errant throw and tried to apply a tag, but the umpire ruled Edwards safe.
“We had to finally hit,” Valancius said. “No one was hitting them. We made [Travis Babin] look like some great pitcher.”
Pat Sarkissian and Valancius followed with singles to load the bases for Valaika. The sophomore promptly lined a two-run single into right to tie the game, 4-4. Later in the inning, with two outs and the bases loaded, Travis Babin stopped a comebacker of Shane Carlson’s bat and ran it to first. As soon as Babin hit the bag, he let out a holler and was flocked by teammates.
“There was never a dull moment after that,” Babin said.
The Indians’ seventh-inning surge seemed to turn the game in their favor for the first time. Sanchez retired seven straight off the mound between the seventh and 10th innings. Prior to that, the Indians’ pitchers had trouble just throwing strikes.
Meanwhile, Hart worked the bases loaded again in the eighth, but that too was thwarted on a comebacker to Babin.
“Your shoulders feel the weight just drop off,” Babin said.
The game remained locked at 4-4 until the top of the 11th when a throwing error by Hart second baseman Shane Carlson allowed Babin to score the tie-breaking run.
Carlson’s glovework, however, approached the spectacular leading up to that gaffe. In the top of the fourth, he stole a hit away from Jeff Knosp, straying into shallow right field. The one-time Centurion spun and threw to first for the out. Babin reached base in the 11th despite a backhanded stop, turn and throw by Carlson.
Eaton upped the Centurions’ lead to 6-4 with a single to right, scoring Bridges.
The daylight was escaping Bud Murray Field by the time Hart caught up to Saugus again.
“We were celebrating a tie,” Valancius said, “and it doesn’t prove anything,”
For one day, at least, there was tying in baseball.
