It’s not about paybacks. It’s about property rights — and, as in so many cases that go before city planners and the City Council, the Melody Ranch proposal for a new sound stage comes down to conflicting sets of property rights.
The conditional use permit for the sound stage was approved Tuesday on a 3-1 city Planning Commission vote, but considering the local opposition in Placerita Canyon, there’s a good chance the matter will be appealed to the City Council — which will then face the same question the Planning Commission did:
Which property rights will prevail?
On one hand, you have the neighbors of the Placerita Canyon motion picture studio who complain, among other things, that movie trucks and other vehicles are making the twisting, private canyon road unsafe — and are arriving too early in the morning to allow a reasonable chance at a good night’s sleep.
And on the other hand, you have the members of the Veluzat family who have owned the former Gene Autry motion picture studio and ranch property since 1990, when they restored the historic parcel, including the once-burned “western town” movie set.
The Melody Ranch property owners have a bustling business on their hands — the HBO series “Deadwood” films there, as well as other series and features. They simply want to build the sound stage to improve Melody Ranch as a filming location and continue the success of the business. There’s nothing wrong with that.
Co-owners Renaud and Andre Veluzat have been good “corporate citizens” of Santa Clarita, opening up the historic Melody Ranch property one weekend each year for the past decade to serve as the venue for the city of Santa Clarita’s Cowboy Poetry and Music Festival. However, approving the sound stage should be more than simply a gesture of thanks for the Veluzats’ good will, which has, undoubtedly, been a monumental factor in the success of the cowboy poetry festival.
We believe the commission made the right decision, and the council should follow suit, simply because the sound stage proposal stands on its own merits. Filming in general is a major contributor to the Santa Clarita Valley economy, and it’s just the sort of business local leaders want to promote. It’s not as if the property owner has suddenly expressed a desire to dramatically alter the land use or create a blight on the community.
Yes, provisions should be made to help ensure that the filming operation is a good neighbor — and that might include outreach efforts to the film industry personnel who come to Melody Ranch. Certainly, the neighbors’ concerns shouldn’t be dismissed without any attempt to address them. But the bottom line is the new sound stage is an extension of a property use that has existed there dating back to the 1920s, and seems to be a logical addition to the site.
Hopefully, if the issue makes its way to the City Council, a resolution will be reached that allows Melody Ranch to build the new sound stage but also to ease the concerns of the studio’s neighbors in Placerita Canyon.
