The 2004 City Council race will go into the history books as a yawner. Mayor Bob Kellar and Councilman Cameron Smyth were successful in their quest for a second term, facing but one challenger who gave it a good, if insufficient, run for his money — or rather, his lack thereof.
Smyth raised somewhere in the neighborhood of $60,000, mounting an effective absentee ballot program that gave him an early and commanding lead in mail-in voting. Kellar raised around $80,000 and plastered his name onto four-by-eight plywood signs on virtually every vacant lot with four-lane frontage.
Henry Schultz didn’t compete in the absentee balloting, but held his own on election day. He actually finished one vote ahead of Kellar among those who cast ballots in person. Not a bad showing for someone who barely raised a tenth of the money the incumbents brought in.
But that wasn’t the full extent of the campaign spending. One special interest in particular flexed its muscle to the tune of about $14,000.
The spending was done by something called the Newhall Civic Improvement Association, an outfit that seems to exist only when there’s a Santa Clarita City Council election going on. It sent a mailer to Republican households urging a vote for the two Republicans, Kellar and Smyth.
Most of the money for the mailer, $12,000, came from a single source, Larry Rasmussen, a local developer who’s always got several irons in the city’s fire.
In truth, it was a drop in the bucket that was only marginally effective in a race that saw the candidates put out several mailers of their own. The difference is, the candidates — Kellar, Smyth and Schultz — had to conform to a different set of fund-raising rules than Rasmussen’s NCIA.
Candidates are restricted to gathering contributions of no more than $360 from a single source. But organizations like the NCIA can raise and spend however much they want.
The NCIA is what’s known as a political action committee, or PAC. By law, it must stay at arm’s length from a candidate’s own campaign committee.
Reality is a bit different from legalities in small elections like ours. In reality, where there’s a player who wants to pump more than $360 into a council campaign, somebody forms a PAC, accepts his money, and spends it to promote his candidate.
PAC spending made a bigger difference in 2002, dumping $72,000 into the City Council election. Much came from Waste Management Inc., which was vying for the city’s lucrative trash-hauling contracts at the time.
Smyth tried to convince his council colleagues that something needed to be done to rein in the special-interest spending. He wanted PACs to be able to raise no more than $250 from a single source, versus the unlimited amount they can otherwise raise.
With the exception of Councilwoman Laurene Weste, the council couldn’t muster sufficient intestinal fortitude to move Smyth’s proposal off the table.
As an excuse, they muttered something about “local” PACs versus “state” PACs that was factually incorrect. The cities of Agoura Hills and even Los Angeles have per-donor limits of $250 and $500, respectively, to PACs — all of which must file papers with the state if they raise $1,000 or more.
Councilman Frank Ferry even had the gall to suggest allowing council candidates to accept $1,000 per donor instead of the then-current $250. The council hemmed, hawed, and finally settled on the weird figure of $360.
The council went backward and did nothing to level the playing field or curtail the special-interest spending.
Now that the 2004 election is over, the council should revisit Smyth’s PAC reforms and approve them this time. The council should make it clear, as we head into the 2006 election cycle, that special-interest influence peddling has no place in Santa Clarita.
