The Santa Clarita City Council denied a variance for the Santa Clarita Athletic Club sign near Interstate 5 in Newhall despite suggestions by an attorney that the case would wind up in court.
“A flat-out denial is not going to solve the problem,” attorney Mark M. Geyer told council members Tuesday night.
“I’m a litigator,” he said, although he added he would prefer to “meet and confer” on the issue of the 39-foot-tall, 473-square-foot sign.
Geyer also accused City Attorney Carl Newton of threatening to have the Athletic Club’s conditional use permits revoked if the business’ owner, Charles Hamilton, did not agree to remove or modify the sign. Newton denied making any threat.
Council members noted that the city’s ordinance regulating the size and height of signs in the city went into effect in 1999 after a nine-year grace period for businesses to make adjustments. The Santa Clarita Athletic Club opened on the site during the grace period and has been discussing the issue with city staff since 2001, but the two sides remain far apart.
“The suggestion that we will wind up in litigation ... we’re not going to be intimidated by that,” Mayor Bob Kellar said before the council unanimously turned down the variance.
“You have an excellent business there, sir,” Kellar said to Hamilton. “Your sign is not part of it.”
A city hearing officer and the Planning Commission had previously denied the variance.
The city’s sign ordinance allows businesses to have signs up to 35 feet high and 200 square feet. The Athletic Club, whose sign dates to the property’s previous use as an auto dealership, is not only oversized but includes flashing lights that spell messages to passing motorists.
A plan from city staff would allow the business to keep the lights if it agreed to lower the height of the sign and redesign it to make it more attractive. But that would cost more than $300,000, Geyer said. Hamilton’s plan to revamp the sign would cost him about $140,000, the attorney said, but leave it at its current height.
Three residents testified in support of the city’s stand during a public hearing on the sign.
“Our area is blighted because of the sign,” Annette Lucas said. Motorists entering the Santa Clarita Valley on the northbound I-5 “look at this ratty little area before (they) come into our city.”
David Royer noted that the site’s original occupant, a Datsun dealer, erected the sign to attract business from the freeway.
“People don’t drive down the freeway looking for an athletic club to pull in and do business,” he said.
Councilman Cameron Smyth questioned Hamilton’s claim that he would lose hundreds of thousands of dollars in business if the sign came down.
