The attorney of a Canyon Country man accused of aiding and abetting in the murder of Byron Benito told a jury the prosecution’s case lacks the evidence needed to convict his client.
Attorney Alex Kessell stood behind Samuel Herr, 20, and said prosecutors James Garrison and John Cohello failed to show any evidence that his client had any knowledge of the plot to kill Benito, a Canyon Country resident.
Herr is one of six defendants accused of planning the stabbing assault on Benito during the night of Jan. 15, 2002 in the street of the Greenbrier East Mobile Home Park in Canyon Country. At least 17 others, who investigators said were gang members and associates, were arrested.
Closing arguments will continue before Judge Norman P. Tarle in Superior Court today for Jose de Jesus Rodriguez, 21, of Canyon Country, Robert Moreno Jr., 20, Tony Villasenor, 21, Adam Rodriguez, 24, and Esteban, 21. The defendants pleaded innocent to the murder in October 2002.
Kessell told the jury he did his best to show how prosecutors were unable to connect Herr to the alleged gang conspiracy to luring Benito to his death as possible retaliation in a gang member’s death. Herr is accused of driving the victim from his home to the senior mobile home park after the plot was conceived, then returning to the home to learn of the outcome.
“I have been Sam’s lawyer for two years now and I have to give this up to you,” Kessell said. “It’s in your hands now. You have to find Sam Herr, beyond a reasonable doubt, was in that room to convict him.”
During the trial, two witnesses testified under an immunity agreement that a plot was discussed within the bedroom of one witnesses’ Santa Clarita apartment. Authorities have asked The Signal not to reveal her identity, but a second witness was identified as Issac Rodriguez, cousin of two of the defendants.
Felix Martinez, attorney for defendant Jose Rodriguez, said Rodriguez testified against his cousins and the other gang members because he was a juvenile and could serve time in the California Youth Authority until age 25 rather than receive an adult sentence of life without possibility of parole.
Martinez claims there is no direct evidence linking his client to the scene of the crime, but admits Rodriguez was “in the mix” of the crime.
“There’s not enough evidence to convict my client,” Martinez said. “No fingerprints, no blood, no fiber, no hair — nothing was found.”
