A jury cleared six men Thursday of a cumulative total of 30 charges in the gang-related murder of a Canyon Country man Thursday.
Canyon Country residents Jose de Jesus Rodriguez, 21, Samuel Herr, 20, Tony Villasenor, 21, Adam Rodriguez, 24, Robert Moreno Jr., 20, and Esteban Alonso, 21, were found not guilty of five counts each in the fatal stabbing of Byron Benito, 19. They were charged with murder, conspiracy to commit murder, special circumstance allegations of lying in wait and other lesser charges.
Benito was found lying on a street in the Greenbrier East Mobile Home Park after being beaten and stabbed in a nearby parking lot during the night of Jan. 15, 2002. Detectives believe Benito was attacked by at least 17 gang members and associates to avenge the death of Victor Flores, 19, of Piru, whose body was found in a dry creek bed near Sierra Highway the previous day.
Eleven other defendants were found guilty in prior court proceedings.
James Blatt, attorney for Moreno, said he spoke with the jury foreperson who said the prosecution’s case was insufficient to convict any of the defendants.
“The foreperson told me there were too many holes in the prosecution’s case,” Blatt said. “Both witnesses had a lot of baggage. One was caught lying and the other claimed innocence but pled guilty to murder (to serve time) in the juvenile system.”
Issac Rodriguez, cousin of the Rodriguez defendants, and a Santa Clarita woman whose bedroom was used to plan the surprise attack on Benito, testified against the accused. The woman, whose identity is being protected by attorneys, testified under an immunity agreement with the district attorney’s office.
But unclear details dulled her testimony and a confession of heavy drinking while the defendants moved in and out of her apartment led the jury to believe she was not a good witness, Blatt said.
Prosecutor James Garrison was not available for comment.
Blatt said his client was the least culpable because Moreno was not present at the scene of the beating and was not involved in the assault.
Joseph Gutierrez, attorney for Villasenor, said his client was still being processed out of the system but knew he felt relieved at the not guilty verdict.
“I think he will go home to his family to re-evaluate his life,” Gutierrez said.
Gutierrez said he was also relieved that the jury was able to “rise above the cloud of gang bias” and determine guilt or innocence on an individual basis.
“The jury had a difficult job and proved the system works,” Gutierrez said.
