ArchiveSCV
the-signal.com. The Santa Clarita Valley Signal. Back to the collection.

· the-signal.com, Wayback capture

Newhall Water board ends exercise in failure

In the end, the Newhall County Water District’s board of directors failed.

Failure is about the only way to describe it when four elected adults cannot sufficiently resolve their differences to fill a vacant board seat, then two of them no-show for the board’s final opportunity to handle the matter itself before it is moved up the food chain to the county Board of Supervisors.

That’s exactly what happened Tuesday night, when the water district’s board couldn’t muster a quorum.

It was the board’s final opportunity to decide for itself how to fill the vacancy created by the resignation of Richard Unger, who moved out of the area.

It seemed appropriate for the remaining board members to fill the vacancy: Only 16 months remain on the four-year term, so whoever is appointed will soon be subject to voter approval, and a special election would be costly.

But the appointment never happened.

Now, the decision moves to the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors, which will get the task of filling Unger’s seat for the NCWD board, much like a parent intervening to settle a squabble between two children fighting over a toy.

The four remaining board members have been divided into two factions:

Barbara Dore and Randall Pfiester, generally identified as pro-business board members, wanted to appoint former board member Valerie Thomas, who lost her seat to Joan Dunn in November.

Dunn and Lynne Plambeck — generally identified as anti-growth, environmentalist board members — wanted to appoint Mike Kotch, who also previously served on the board.

There were three other candidates for the vacancy — Carolyn Shaffer, Thomas R. Gavin and Maria A. Gutzeit-Fahrenholz, who are relative unknowns.

For the past month, the two sides each maintained a death grip on their positions, with Dore and Pfiester holding firm in favor of Thomas and Dunn and Plambeck doing the same in favor of Kotch.

At a special meeting last week, Plambeck suggested that both Kotch and Thomas be removed from consideration, with the board choosing one of the three other candidates to fill the vacancy.

We endorsed Thomas in last year’s election and we believe she would have been a good choice for the spot — but considering the stalemate, Plambeck’s suggestion was reasonable: If the two sides couldn’t agree to appoint one of the two strongly allied candidates, why not bring in some new blood, someone who may not have strong allegiance to either side?

That would have been an effective compromise and may have helped bring a fresh approach to the board. With any luck, it would have given the board a makeup similar to what it had before Unger left: Two representatives from each of the above-mentioned “camps,” and a fifth member who is something of a centrist.

That suggestion did not fly — the “unknowns” were dismissed out of hand by at least one board member — and a Tuesday meeting was scheduled as one last shot for the board to resolve the matter itself.

What happened?

Well, it appears as if two board members simply shirked their responsibility to try to resolve the problem: Dore and Pfiester no-showed for the meeting, leaving Plambeck and Dunn unable to conduct board business without a quorum.

It is, of course, always conceivable that a given board member has a legitimate reason for missing a meeting. But this particular occurrence smacks of collusion: By skipping the meeting, Dore and Pfiester have forced the decision into the hands of the county supervisors.

If in fact that was an intentional tactic, it constitutes a rather blatant abdication of their responsibility as board members. In the past, we have typically agreed with Dore and Pfiester on local issues — but we cannot advocate such tactics.

The Board of Supervisors covers a lot of territory in its day-to-day business, so it’s not likely that the supervisors have an intimate level of familiarity with the issues and operation of the Newhall County Water District — not to mention the suitability of individual candidates.

The four remaining Newhall water board members, however, are familiar with such things and were well-equipped to make that decision and evaluate the three “newcomer” candidates.

All four share in the responsibility for their collective failure, and two of them share in the responsibility for their failure to take one last stab at crafting a compromise.

It’s a pity, really: The board’s vacancy will be filled by the less-familiar county supervisors — or, perhaps, by a costly special election — because the four remaining board members couldn’t find a way to play nice.

← Back to 2002

About this record

How it was held, read and classified

Record details

Morris ID
Not a Morris ID. This record is keyed ts-vs:462.
System
ViewStory pages (/News/ViewStory.asp)
Reading copy
the-signal.com
Chosen by: only copy held. On this copy: words 762 (e-mail addresses counted as one token); reader comments 0 (counted, not reproduced here); images 0.
Extracted by
viewstory:font_body
signal-extract/0.15 (2026-11-16)

Other copies

Held
None. The holding has this article from one host only.

How it was classified

Label
clearly-local
Judgment
A machine’s (recorded as machine), kept as one so it can be revisited.
Classifier
signal-localclass/0.7 (2026-11-12)
Local signals
  • byline:staff_marker [Editorial from The Signal; The Newspaper's Opinion]
  • text:valley_names [2 distinct/6 mentions: Newhall, Newhall County Water]
National signals
none fired
Scores
local 5, national 0