We’re saying the answer should be, “No, Marcus Lellan should not be deported.”
Please, don’t mistake this for a lack of compassion for those whose loved ones were killed in the Feb. 17, 2000, crash, caused when Lellan attempted an unsafe, high-speed pass on Soledad Canyon Road.
Rather, it’s based on careful consideration of the crime and punishment, in the context of the law of the land.
The reckless actions of Lellan, then 18, killed three of his friends — Dominick Ianozzi, 17, and brothers Timothy and Danny Renolds, 18 and 15 — and also killed Rodney “Rocky” Adams, 45, of Canyon Country. The three youths were passengers in Lellan’s Acura when it crossed the center divider, flipped and landed on top of Adams’ oncoming car.
Lellan and another passenger, 16-year-old Daniel Weber, survived. Lellan pleaded guilty less than two months later to four felony counts of vehicular manslaughter with gross negligence, and was sentenced to eight years in state prison.
As is often the case in today’s flawed criminal justice system, Lellan served just over half of his sentence before being released from prison April 16. But Lellan was not freed; he was transferred into the custody of the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services.
The USCIS, formerly the Immigration and Naturalization Service, will determine whether Lellan is to be deported due to his offense.
You see, although Lellan, now 22, has lived in the United States since he was 7 years old, he is a citizen of Denmark. Typically, foreign nationals convicted of an “aggravated felony” are deported, and Lellan’s crime could be considered an aggravated felony. A hearing on the matter has yet to be scheduled.
Obviously, rules are rules. But if discretion can be applied at all in this case, Lellan should be allowed to stay in the United States. He has already served the sentence any citizen would have served under the same circumstances, he’s not likely to pose a further criminal threat and the only reason to boot him out of the country at this point is that his birth certificate does not say “United States.”
A reasonable question can be raised about whether the sentencing guidelines for crimes like Lellan’s are in fact stringent enough — he could have gotten 10 years under the guidelines, and was sentenced to eight. After all, if your loved ones were killed in such a crash, due to gross negligence and recklessness, you would naturally feel that just a little over four years of time actually served is an insufficient punishment.
That’s only natural and understandable.
When it comes to deportation, you’re actually talking about tacking on a sentence that’s much more severe than any prison term that any U.S. citizen would serve for the same crime — and while Lellan is not, technically, a U.S. citizen, at the time of his crime he was for all intents and purposes an American teenager who made a grievous, costly error that, make no mistake, warranted criminal punishment.
But he cannot be equated with hardened criminals who enter this country with the intent to commit crime, use guns in the process and intentionally inflict harm on innocents. Lellan, through his actions behind the wheel, cemented the fact that his name in this community will forever be linked with tragic, unnecessary death. But no one believes he intentionally set out to kill.
Considering this, whatever the outcome with the immigration system, he should not return to the Santa Clarita Valley, if nothing else out of consideration for the families whose lives were devastated in February 2000. Imagine being one of those who suffered such a horrible loss, and seeing the driver at the grocery store. They should not be subjected to that.
However, we do believe Lellan ought to be allowed to try to put together some semblance of an adult life — in the United States.
