In past years, we’ve defended the pay raises given to Dianne Van Hook, superintendent-president of College of the Canyons, based on our belief that she is a dynamic leader whose hard work, tenacity and dedication have provided major benefits, financial and otherwise, to our local community college.
We still believe those things to be true.
However, when the COC Board of Trustees meets tonight to weigh another big increase for Van Hook, we suggest that they think long and hard before granting such a large raise.
It’s not that Van Hook isn’t doing a good job. She is. It’s simply that her compensation is growing so rapidly as to raise questions about whether the board is being responsible to the taxpayers in its negotiations with her.
In 2002, Van Hook received a 10 percent pay raise that brought her salary to $212,000 per year. That approximately $19,000 raise was followed in 2003 by an $18,000 increase, bringing her salary to $230,000.
If she gets the raise she’s expected to get tonight — $16,000 — Van Hook’s compensation will have increased by more than $50,000 in just three years, to $246,000.
That would be one thing if she were in private industry. But as the superintendent of the community college, she is a public employee. There is another level of accountability that has to come into play, and the sheer size of the numbers bears careful examination by the board and the community before approval.
Again, this isn’t about whether Van Hook does a good job, especially when it comes to securing COC’s share of state resources. Her success in that regard is undisputed. That’s part of her job, and she does it well. The argument can easily be made that she goes above and beyond the call of duty.
But the argument can also be made that Van Hook’s compensation already reflects that.
She’s among the state’s highest paid community college executives and she’s already received $37,000 in increases over the past two years. So it’s not as if Van Hook’s prowess and dedication as an administrator and advocate for COC have gone unnoticed or unrewarded.
Simply put, there comes a time when the pay has reached the level of appropriateness for the job, especially considering it’s the taxpayers’ money. (Heck, the governor’s salary is “only” $175,000...)
No one is suggesting Van Hook should never receive another increase; rather, we’re suggesting that the rate of escalation seems excessive at this point.
If nothing else, the board should seriously examine the amount of the increase and consider whether the superintendent’s pay is ascending too rapidly, especially at a time when the state is in a budget crisis and public agencies everywhere are looking for ways to save a few nickels and dimes. A $16,000 raise right now is an odd message to send.
The board has already discussed the matter once, in closed session, and it’s on the agenda for tonight’s board meeting. Before a final vote is taken, we ask that the board revisit the issue, and make sure its decision is not only reflective of Van Hook’s strengths and hard work, but is also responsible to the taxpayers.
