Browning Ferris Industries has formally withdrawn its application for permits to operate Elsmere Canyon as a giant trash dump, apparently conceding defeat in a more than 15-year-long battle between the giant trash hauler and Santa Clarita Valley residents.
“This is really a wonderful, wonderful accomplishment,” City Councilwoman Marsha McLean said Monday. “It took a lot of work and lot of time and a lot of effort, and finally they’ve done it.”
In a letter dated May 5 but released Monday, BFI District Manager Greg Loughnane wrote, “BFI of California Inc. formally withdraws its application for a conditional use permit and oak tree (removal) permit ... for the proposed Elsmere Solid Waste Management Facility.”
BFI owns about 1,200 acres of Elsmere Canyon, which is located to the east of state Route 14 just north of the Newhall Pass. The city of Santa Clarita and county Supervisor Michael D. Antonovich have battled to prevent the canyon from the same fate as Sunshine Canyon, a landfill operated by BFI just south and west of the Newhall Pass.
Elsmere, which is most easily accessible through Whitney Canyon at the dead-end of San Fernando Road, is a riparian habitat with many streams and waterfalls, including one 50 feet high. About 8,000 oaks dot the acreage.
Whitney Canyon is jointly owned by the city of Santa Clarita and the Santa Monica Mountains Conservancy. It has been set aside as open space.
McLean, who led the battle against the dump for more than 15 years, said the victory is not yet complete.
The canyon must be taken off the county siting element, she said.
The siting element is a document the county must present to the state every five years; any major changes, including the removal of Elsmere, would have to be approved by a majority of the other cities in the county, Antonovich spokesman Paul Novak said in an earlier interview.
The future of the 1,200 acres owned by BFI also must be resolved, McLean said.
The area has tremendous “cultural and historical value, and perhaps they would like to make an endowment” to the public, she said.
“It would help their image, and it would help them with their taxes,” she said.
“Hopefully, it won’t take too many more years before Elsmere Canyon is where it belongs, and that’s in the public ownership.”
