Thirteen years and counting.
Whatever the final outcome, the Cemex mining project will likely go down in the books as the longest running legal battle in Santa Clarita Valley history.
A federal court ruling earlier this month will allow Cemex to move ahead with the mining of 78 million tons of sand and gravel in Soledad Canyon over the next 20 years. According to the consent decree, the anticipated royalty to the U.S. government from mineral rights on the project site will be about $28 million.
After Judge Dickran Tevrizian’s approval of the consent decree, which settles litigation between Cemex, the federal government and the county of Los Angeles, supporters believe the controversial project will finally become reality.
But opponents say it’s still possible to defeat the project, and the saga could continue for several more years. More than 100 local organizations and elected representatives at several levels of government oppose the mine.
Either way, all sides are vowing to keep up their fight. The city of Santa Clarita, Los Angeles County, Cemex and U.S. Rep. Howard “Buck” McKeon are all playing a role in the ongoing story.
q q q
“It’s fair to say that we are broadening our legal attack on this project,” said Deborah Prosser, an attorney for the city.
“We are filing an appeal with the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals challenging the consent decree,” City Attorney Carl Newton said. “We expect to do that later this month.
“The other parties will likely move forward to follow the direction of the consent decree, but the city will pursue all legal options that protect the city’s interests within the specified time allowed by law,” Newton said. “Once the county moves to approve the project, the city will challenge the approval on CEQA (California Environmental Quality Act) grounds,” he said. “Their approval will also trigger the filing of a new case in federal court.”
The appeals process could last up to two years.
The city of Santa Clarita was not allowed to intervene in the lawsuit until a May 3 court hearing. The city’s attorneys presented what they said was newly discovered information, including the discovery of endangered southwestern arroyo toads at the mining site. They argued against the project, saying the city had the right to be directly involved in the court process.
There is unanimous opposition to the project from the neighboring communities of Palmdale, Lancaster, Acton and Agua Dulce.
Santa Clarita has spent between $3 million and $4 million trying to stop the project.
q q q
The county Board of Supervisors tried to block the project by refusing to certify its environmental impact report in 2002. Now, the supervisors plan to comply with their negotiated settlement.
“The county is taking steps to comply with the consent decree,” county attorney Richard Weiss said.
The supervisors voted 3-2 to settle a protracted lawsuit in which Cemex accused the county of overstepping its authority when it rejected the federally approved mine. Supervisors Michael D. Antonovich and Zev Yaroslavsky voted not to settle.
“Supervisor Antonovich has been adamantly opposed to this project since day one, because of environmental, health and public safety issues,” Antonovich spokesman Tony Bell said.
“Mr. Antonovich dissented, but the board passed it anyway,” he said.
According to the 63-page decree, the county must complete and certify the final EIR, approve surface mining permits, and approve a reclamation plan within 60 days after May 6.
q q q
Cemex is making plans to move forward with the expansion of its operations, and says the Soledad Canyon mining project will benefit the community of Santa Clarita.
“We are happy with the agreement that was reached between the parties, and are enthusiastic about moving forward,” said Brian Mastin, manager of environmental affairs for Cemex.
“The county is required to issue permits, finalize the EIRs, and approve the reclamation,” he said.
Asked if he felt that Cemex had been treated unfairly, Mastin said, “We did allege that in our complaint with the court, but that has been resolved to the benefit of all parties.”
The consent decree says Cemex has paid a high price to get where it is today.
“Cemex has pursued permitting and implementation of the project for nearly 13 years, and has incurred extraordinary costs during this process.”
q q q
Lawmakers are attempting to strike a last-minute deal with Cemex in hopes of heading off the giant open-pit mine.
Santa Clarita Mayor Bob Kellar and City Manager Ken Pulskamp traveled to Washington, D.C., for a meeting Friday with McKeon, the Bureau of Land Management, and Cemex.
McKeon, R-Santa Clarita, said the meeting went well.
“The meeting was intended to bring all the parties into the same room so they could fully and openly discuss their individual perspectives on the matter, and we successfully accomplished that purpose,” McKeon said in a statement.
“While no negotiations took place today, the meeting was yet another important step, and left me cautiously hopeful that through continued dialogue, we can find a creative resolution to this matter. I expect this to be a long and arduous process, and I will keep our community informed as further developments come to light,” the statement said.
McKeon has said he hopes to broker a deal by convincing Cemex to swap its rights to mine the Soledad Canyon property for mining rights on BLM-managed land elsewhere in his district. McKeon’s 25th Congressional District includes 3 million acres of federally owned land.
McKeon said in previous interviews that it will be a tough sell, because the BLM would gain nothing in return except good will.
McKeon had said BLM officials and Gilberto Perez, president of Cemex’s U.S. operations, were receptive to the idea of talks, and expressed confidence in his ability to broker a deal.
“This meeting was a positive, solution-oriented meeting,” Pulskamp said Friday.
“We had the opportunity to explain how committed we are to protecting the public from any negative effects of the mine project,” Pulskamp said.
Pulskamp had praise for Perez.
“He wants to develop a win-win situation for all sides,” Pulskamp said. “He (Perez) is willing to look at other minerals and sites, and assign staff for us to work with.”
Asked if the city still plans to take further legal action, Pulskamp said, “We are not disbanding any options, but we would really prefer to work with them toward a solution.”
As for the next step, Pulskamp said, “I will be contacting the Cemex office Monday morning to discuss where we can go from here.”
