It’s not a priesthood. No one expects public officials to take a vow of poverty. But... We do expect public agencies to hold themselves accountable to taxpayers, to spend our money responsibly, and prudently. That includes paying public employees salaries that are fair — but not excessive.
It can be a difficult line to walk. Think of it as a fiscal tightrope.
When you’re dealing with a public agency budget in the tens of millions, and an organization that employs hundreds and serves thousands, the salary of the chief executive isn’t necessarily a “large” expense, percentage-wise. But it is an important symbolic expense.
We’ve seen this fact illustrated dramatically in the past couple of years when it comes to the salary of Dianne Van Hook, the superintendent-president of College of the Canyons.
No doubt, her salary should be significant. It should be the highest on campus. This much, no one debates.
COC serves thousands of Santa Clarita Valley residents, and serves them well. It is one of our valley’s most prized and respected entities, and rightfully so.
That is due largely to the job done by the people at COC — from the part-time faculty member who teaches one math class, to the full-time instructors, to the staff, coaches, deans, office employees... everyone who contributes to making COC such a vibrant community institution.
That includes the superintendent.
There’s no denying the role Dianne Van Hook has played in COC’s success. Through her leadership, the college has dramatically grown and expanded its role as a local educational institution.
Van Hook works hard. She’s a force of nature, twisting arms in Sacramento to bring funding — including hard-won construction dollars — back home to Valencia. She’s smart, and aggressive. I’ve never known anyone who has a greater command of facts and figures than Van Hook. These qualities have served COC well for the past decade and a half.
Yet, it bears remembering that, even before her most recent raises, she has been extremely well-compensated for her efforts. I won’t say she’s not “worth” $246,000 per year — who knows what she could make in private industry — but I will say this: The COC Board of Trustees is not handling her compensation in a way that builds taxpayer and staff trust.
In the past three years, Van Hook has received more than $50,000 in salary increases — just the increases! — including a $16,000 raise the board gave her a couple of weeks ago.
You don’t take a vow of poverty when you go to work for a public entity, but there is a different sort of responsibility and accountability. Go to work for a corporation and you’re accountable to the owners, stockholders. Go to work for a public agency, and you’re accountable to the owners, too: Every one of us.
Someone working for a public agency may not make the same salary he or she would make in private industry, but there are different rewards when you have a job that contributes to the public betterment.
Is $200,000 a year not enough? Then perhaps private industry is the way to go.
Even before Van Hook’s $50,000-plus in raises over the past three years, she was making a great living. She was already among the most highly compensated public employees before this most recent raise (the governor’s salary is “only” $175,000, and he runs the whole state...)
Both Van Hook and the COC board need to give more consideration to the message her hefty, rapid-fire salary hikes send, especially at a time when staffers are being told to stretch resources and the state is in the midst of a budget crisis. The way the board and Van Hook have handled the issue is devoid of humility.
And to those who say, “Well, she brings in a lot of money...” I ask, “Since when are community college superintendents on commission?”
You don’t hear much on this issue from the faculty. However, behind the scenes, there’s a rumbling that many of them are resentful of Van Hook’s extravagant pay, especially under current circumstances, but are simply afraid to speak out. Job security is a powerful motivating force.
I applaud COC board member Ron Gillis for his courageous vote against the pay increase. It would have been all too easy to go along with the strong political momentum that was marshaled in support of the increase.
This is nothing against Van Hook. Her dedication to improving COC, and the energy she brings to the job, are beyond question. She does a good job of bringing home the bacon, and that’s great. But what seems lost on four members of the COC board — and on Van Hook, too — is the fact that it’s not the extra $16,000 that really matters.
It’s the message.
Tim Whyte is The Signal’s managing editor.
