It’s not the sort of local connection that a community likes to have to an international news story, but here we are:
John B. Israel, a 48-year-old Santa Clarita resident, has been accused of being one of those responsible for the U.S. military’s abuse of Iraqi detainees at the Abu Ghraib prison.
Israel is a civilian interpreter employed by SOS Interpreting Ltd. He, along with one other civilian contractor and two military officers, has been identified by Maj. Gen. Antonio Taguba as being “either directly or indirectly responsible” for the mistreatment of prisoners by U.S. guards.
The accusation was made in the so-called “Taguba report,” which was completed by Taguba in March and mistakenly released in April.
This week, we learned that one of the four whom Taguba described as being part of the chain of command that led to the abuses is actually a resident of our own town.
You won’t find that piece of information on the tourism brochures any time soon.
Taguba, in May 11 testimony to the Senate Armed Services Committee, said Mr. Israel and the other civilian contractor did not have official authority to command the soldiers, but that “the guards, those who were involved, looked at them as competent authority...”
Taguba also testified that the two civilians answered to the Joint Interrogation and Debriefing Center, which answered to a lieutenant colonel, Steve L. Jordan, who answered to the brigade commander, Col. Thomas M. Pappas.
Damning statements, yes?
That would be the appearance. However, it is important to remember something that often seems lost on our 24-hour-news-cycle society:
The presumption of innocence.
It is certainly within the realm of possibility that John Israel bears responsibility for the soldiers’ abuse and humiliation of Iraqi prisoners. But it is also possible that he is innocent — scapegoats, after all, are in high demand these days.
We will not judge either Israel or those who accuse him at this stage. We are obligated to report to you everything that we can possibly find out regarding this story — it is, after all, a local link to a series of incidents that have dominated world news in recent weeks.
Regardless, though, Mr. Israel, like anyone, is entitled to due process — and none of us should forget that.
