“Shop Local” or “Shop Santa Clarita”? To most Santa Clarita residents, the two phrases probably seem synonymous.
They’re not. The folks at City Hall want people to “Shop Santa Clarita,” while the directors of the chamber of commerce favor “Shop Local.”
More than just splitting hairs, the city and the chamber are at odds over a campaign that would seek to keep area shoppers inside city limits.
Beginning in July, the City Council is planning to invest $88,000 of your tax dollars in an ad blitz to convince you to patronize local businesses. It’s a comeback for a similar program that was credited for driving $850 million in sales to Valencia’s Auto Row alone.
The point of the program was to teach people the importance of spending their shopping dollars locally.
Don’t shop on your lunch hour in Los Angeles when you can find the same item in Santa Clarita on your way home. Don’t take the family to dinner in Westwood when you can get a fine meal at Salt Creek. And for gosh sakes, don’t buy a car in the San Fernando Valley when you can buy the same model here.
Why? Because a portion of the tax dollars you spend in Santa Clarita stay in Santa Clarita.
One cent of the sales tax you pay on every $1 purchase goes to the city’s general fund. Those pennies add up every year to new roads and parks, police officers, fire fighters and most of the other services the city provides.
But that’s only true when you make your purchase inside the city’s municipal boundaries. Buy a stuffed Warner Bros. character at Magic Mountain or eat at the Red Lobster, and the local portion of your sales tax dollars go to the county — which doesn’t necessarily return all of those dollars to the Santa Clarita Valley in the form of services, the way the city government does.
So this time around, the City Council plans to tailor its “Shop Local” campaign into a “Shop Santa Clarita” campaign. This time the city wants to make darned sure you don’t merely spend your shopping dollars in the Santa Clarita Valley, but rather inside city limits.
To the SCV Chamber of Commerce, that’s heresy.
The chamber represents businesses all across the valley, whether inside or outside city limits. The chamber doesn’t want to see any of its member businesses penalized just because they may be on the wrong side of an arbitrary line in the sand.
The chamber has a point — actually, a few.
First, there are many good, community-minded businesses that are just outside the city, from the Red Lobster, which raises funds for downed officers every year, to Magic Mountain, which supports a wide range of charities.
“(My) store gives back a lot in donations,” says Jimmy Scarpides, owner of Cabo Cabana Fresh Baja Grill in the Valencia Marketplace. “We donate to the (hospital) foundation, we help many churches and schools...”
Scarpides makes a second point.
“We employ a lot of people who live in Santa Clarita,” he says.
Plenty of people who live in Santa Clarita own businesses just outside, and even more city residents are employed by them. Think of Magic Mountain.
When businesses in Sunset Pointe and Stevenson Ranch and Castaic and portions of Valencia, Saugus, Newhall and Canyon Country that lie just outside city limits are successful, their prosperity has a ripple effect throughout the local economy. “Outside” business owners and employees who live in Santa Clarita are likely to shop inside city limits — so the city gets its share of their take.
The city should tread carefully as it crafts its new shopping campaign, and think about the Santa Clarita Valley businesses and workers it could harm if the campaign is too narrowly defined.
Certainly the city’s first responsibility is to the people it represents — which are only those who live inside the city’s municipal boundaries. But by all accounts, the city’s last “Shop Local” campaign was a big success, and even though its true purpose was to promote shopping strictly inside city limits, it didn’t have the divisive overtone that the current campaign has.
If we really want to be one valley, as another city campaign contends, then the council should think twice before driving a new wedge between “us” and “them.”
Leon Worden is The Signal’s city editor.
