Santa Clarita officials hope that putting the city logo or other identifying feature on a credit card will help bolster the city treasury.
But the plan has a ways to go before any payback could be realized.
Under the so-called affinity card program, the city would not be required to front any money. It could get a flat fee for cards issued and a percentage of sales purchased with the card.
The idea is only in the exploratory stages.
“As we find more revenue sources, our goal is to be less dependent on the state and what they decide to do in any given year,” said Assistant City Manager Ken Striplin.
The affinity card is “like a branding tool in getting the city’s name out there, and it also supports the ‘Shop Santa Clarita’ campaign,” Striplin said. “We hope people support local businesses and if having that card helps people have more of a local connection, that’s great.”
The city would not produce the card itself; it would contract with a bank that offers the program. The city could generate money from issuing cards and get a percentage of every dollar cardmembers spend.
“No upfront money or fees are required, and we work with (the city) to develop the program,” said Tanya Turner, vice president of the Affinity Business Unit at U.S. Bank. “We work on a marketing plan and provide a forecast, based on size” of the potential client, she said.
It’s unusual for municipalities to offer such credit cards, Turner said.
U.S. Bank contracted with the city of Huntington Beach for its affinity card.
In the beach city, however, the program has not performed as expected, said Jim Lamb, business development manager for the Huntington Beach Economic Development Department.
“What’s happened is it hasn’t taken off,” he said. “It hasn’t hit those (projected) numbers. (We’ve) looked to see why, even knowing it wouldn’t be instantly successful. I would (still) recommend it today. I think it’s always good to try something new.”
Flyers announcing the program were inserted into Huntington Beach residents’ utility bills in December 2003.
“A lot of people I know have mileage cards, cards that give 1 percent back in cash,” he said.
His city’s affinity card offers no rewards points or frequent flyer miles, but he is looking for a way to link the card to rewards, possibly offering two-day priority registration for those who use the card to pay for recreation programs. It’s critical to offer your citizens a card that has value to them, he said.
“Any city that does this is looking to do something new and different,” Lamb said. “There are not a whole lot of cities doing this.”
Tina Haddad, management analyst for Santa Clarita’s Planning and Building Services, said the city is aware that the card would have to offer incentives to wean cardholders away from their existing cards.
“The recreation program is something we would look into to see if it makes sense (for us),” she said.
“We would be looking at other cities and seeing what incentives they were able to negotiate, and see what would best work for our city” Haddad said.
While they may fuel civic pride, affinity cards are still credit cards.
People who use affinity cards need to make sure they are not spending any differently than they would with other cards, said Jennifer Root, director of public relations for Consumer Credit Counseling Service of Los Angeles.
“Consider the interest rate,” she said. ”It’s not worth spending more on a card if the interest rate is more than on another card.”
Root said one of her company’s main goals is to help people control spending. She recommends setting a budget and not spending more than 20 percent of one’s monthly income on credit card debt.
“If you go over that it should be a red flag to you,” she said. “It’s much better to pay off your balance every month.”
The average nationwide credit card debt is a revolving balance of $7,500, she said.
“Debt is out of control,” she said. “Credit it much easier to come by than it used to be.”
She said teaser rates, offers that encourage one to switch balances for some designated time period, can end up being costly.
Some people cannot help that they lose their jobs, face cutbacks in their industry, face divorce or large medical or legal bills, said Jennifer LaDue, a certified credit counselor with Alliance Credit Counseling, a nationwide nonprofit agency.
“Most people have around $8,000 to $10,000 in unsecured credit card debt,” she said.
She recommends that people who use credit cards start with a small balance, read the fine print and remain vigilant about fluctuating interest rates and unexpected fees.
“One of the reasons creditors get away with so much is because consumers don’t know what their rights are. You can sometimes negotiate lower rates if you’re persistent and know what you want.”
