A federal judge denied Los Angeles County’s request to dismiss a case brought on by the company that wants to install a sand and gravel mine in Soledad Canyon.
Cemex Inc., a Louisiana-based subsidiary of Mexico mining giant Cemex S.A. de C.V., sued the county in January claiming it had actively prevented the company from exercising federal permits. The company has proposed to mine 78 million tons of sand and gravel from a 460-acre parcel east of state Route 14.
The federal Bureau of Land Management issued two, 10-year permits to the company in 1989. However, Cemex needed environmental permits from the county to begin the project.
After a half dozen delays, the county Board of Supervisors unanimously said it wouldn’t issue the needed permits for the project in January.
A Cemex representative called the judges decision a victory.
“The whole issue here has been unnecessarily delayed (by) the county,” said company spokesman Brian Mastin. “We’re anxious to proceed with the case.”
The city of Santa Clarita twice tried to join the lawsuit as an interested party, but was denied both times.
County Deputy Counsel Rick Weiss said the county’s not done fighting.
“We’re disappointed because we thought we had a valid legal argument,” Weiss said.
The county asked the court to dismiss claims that fall under state statutes, not federal, Weiss said. The judge denied the county’s request and will consider all of the arguments made by Cemex.
“(The judges) comments lead us to have some concern that he is buying their argument, that he’s adopting Cemex’s view of the world,” he said. “We do not agree that Cemex’s view of the world is accurate.”
The county and city have maintained that the project’s environmental documentation is flawed and doesn’t address traffic and endangered species impacts.
Cemex agreed to a list of mitigation terms that would lessen the impact on the roads, air and the Santa Clara River, but the company and governments couldn’t work out terms of harsh impacts on Soledad Canyon Road, state Route 14 and endangered species, notably the southwestern arroyo toad, in the river.
Conal McNamara, land-use deputy for Supervisor Michael D. Antonovich, was optimistic that the county would prevail, despite Monday’s ruling.
“The facts will emerge as we go through the process,” McNamara said. “(Cemex’s case) doesn’t do anything to address the environmental concerns brought by the board.”
McNamara said the supervisor looks forward to all the facts coming out during the trial.
A trial date hasn’t been set.
