Service dogs aren’t pets. While that statement might seem like a no-brainer, considerable confusion persists among the general public.
Just what is a service dog? Most people are familiar with seeing-eye dogs, but the truth is, that’s only one type. Individuals with a variety of disabilities, not only total blindness, and not only sight-related, rely on specially trained canines to get through their day.
Ignorance of that fact can lead to trouble. For example, we’ve reported on successful lawsuits against clueless restaurant managers who kicked out sighted patrons who brought their service dogs with them. (Under antidiscrimination statutes, disabled persons cannot be required to produce paperwork proving that their service dog is a service dog.)
Having a service dog is like having a registered nurse who cares for you in your home. It is a medical necessity and is no more a pet than is the nurse.
And yet, county statutes don’t reflect that fact. In Los Angeles County, residents in urban areas are limited to three dogs, whether they’re pet Chihuahuas or medically necessary assistance animals.
Thanks to the efforts of Supervisor Michael D. Antonovich, a well noted dog lover, that’s about to change.
On June 23 the Regional Planning Commission voted to recommend a modification to the county ordinance that limits residents to three dogs. Disabled individuals still would be limited to three pet dogs, but their service animals would be exempted from that cap.
Antonovich, our local supervisor, made the recommendation at the urging of a constituent in Altadena. The constituent already had three pet dogs, then became disabled and needed a service dog. Under existing statutes, she would have had to give up one of her pets.
Why should the law treat her differently from everyone else and restrict her to fewer than three pet dogs? Obviously, it shouldn’t. It’s not like she wanted to go out and become disabled so she could have a fourth dog.
Approved by the planning commission, Antonovich’s proposal will come to the Board of Supervisors for adoption next month. It’s a common-sense solution that should pass easily.
Then again, that’s what we thought about keeping the historic county seal.
