The city of Santa Clarita has sued Los Angeles County, alleging the supervisors violated state environmental protection laws by approving a giant open-pit mine in Soledad Canyon.
The suit, filed Friday in Los Angeles Superior Court, challenges the county’s decision to certify an environmental impact report filed by Mexican cement giant Cemex for its planned sand and gravel mining operation. It also seeks to halt the project.
“The city felt a need to protect its legal interests,” City Attorney Carl Newton said. “The city is very anxious to have a determination made on these issues and is hopeful that we’ll get a favorable court decision that will require the county to revisit this whole issue — approval of the project.”
Assistant County Counsel Richard Weiss said Tuesday he had received word of the suit but had not yet seen it.
“It’s not a surprise to us that the city filed a lawsuit,” he said. “It had indicated it would file a CEQA (California Environmental Quality Act) lawsuit.”
CEQA matters are typically heard quicker than the typical complaint, said Geralyn Skapik, special counsel for the city. Still, the case may not be heard for more than a year because the issue is “complex and complicated,” she said.
The city believes the county should have reconsidered the environmental documents for the project when it received new information from the city late in the planning process, Newton said. Among the late-arriving information was the impact the mine could have on traffic circulation.
The city has long opposed the mining project, which would remove 78 million tons of aggregate from the ground over 20 years.
The lawsuit against the county also names Cemex and the U.S. Department of the Interior as real parties of interest, meaning the suit could affect them.
The Department of the Interior has licensed mineral rights to Cemex for “one of the largest federally licensed sand and gravel mining operations in the United States,” the lawsuit states.
The suit also alleges that Cemex’s proposed “shorter, quicker extraction rate” would invalidate the original federal environmental studies approved by the Interior Department.
Newton said Cemex will be presenting an opposition to the writ on its own behalf and on behalf of the county and federal governments.
In April 2002, the Board of Supervisors voted unanimously to deny Cemex a permit for its proposed project and issued a 35-page report enumerating the flaws in the developer’s environmental impact report. Cemex filed a federal lawsuit before the board’s denial was issued, but that did not alter the 5-0 vote against the project.
The city of Santa Clarita twice tried to intervene as an interested party in the federal suit, but was not permitted to do so by the trial judge, who determined the county would adequately represent the city’s interests.
But the city appealed, and a three-judge panel in San Francisco granted the city the right to intervene. By that time, however, Cemex and the county were nearing a settlement.
The resulting consent decree issued in federal court last March did not recognize the city as an intervener, Skapik said.
As agreed in the consent decree, county supervisors then approved Cemex’s environmental documents and permits on a 3-2 vote, with Supervisors Michael D. Antonovich and Zev Yaroslavsky dissenting.
