Second of three parts.
Picture this: You are ill or injured or slated for surgery. You are admitted to the hospital. Lo and behold, you become the victim of a medical error and wind up being discharged to a mortuary rather than home.
A recent study by HealthGrades, a leading independent health care quality company, reports that this was the fate for nearly 200,000 Americans annually from 2000 to 2002. Some 37 million Medicare patient records from 50 states were studied for the research, which also found that number was nearly double the number of deaths from medical errors found by the 1999 Institute of Medicine’s 28-state report, “To Err is Human.”
A national epidemic, these errors and injuries are a leading cause of death in our country, ahead of diabetes, pneumonia, Alzheimer’s disease, motor vehicle accidents and AIDS. Such lethal gaffes can be found anywhere in our complex, harried health care system — and in the finest of hospitals and allied health care settings. They can include medications, surgery, diagnosis, equipment, lab reports and routine but misinterpreted tasks. Poor communication on the part of physicians as well as between medical caregivers and patients is also to blame.
“Fatal mistakes can sometimes occur by a single person, but it usually takes many people to really screw things up,” says Dr. Steven Brown, an internist, pulmonologist and critical care specialist. “If, for example, I ordered a fatal dose of 2.5 mg of the heart medicine digoxin, instead of 0.25 mg, you would think that the pharmacist who dispenses the drug would give me a call, or the nurse who administers the drug would stop to ponder why Dr. Brown has ordered 10 digoxin pills for a patient.”
Brown’s particular peeve is the failure to recognize the high risk that medical patients have for developing potentially fatal blood clots during hospitalization.
“For patients at risk, which includes almost every immobilized patient, the simple administration of a blood-thinning medication such as heparin or Lovenox can prevent many deaths,” said the Wisconsin doctor.
Another problem relates to inappropriate prevention of infection and misuse of antibiotics.
Doctors, nurses and hospital staff are indeed slow in reducing the risk of serious infections, which occur frequently in hospitalized patients, Brown said, noting that the most common infections that occur in the hospital are urinary tract infections and pneumonia.
“When a patient is in the hospital, the infections are often much more serious, as these bugs have evolved in an environment surrounded by antibiotics,” the physician said. “They are thus resistant to many of our best drugs. We (the health care system) are slow in preventing these infections, in recognizing them when they occur, and in treating them with the appropriate type and strength of antibiotics when infections are recognized.”
Conditions associated with advanced age and infirmity can leave a person vulnerable to medical mishaps.
“I have seen too many very elderly people suffer from dehydration and unnecessary malnutrition from (the) inability to swallow,” Brown said. “Alternately, people are fed when they shouldn’t be fed — either because they are to have procedures, or their swallow mechanism is faulty based on age, debilitation, neurological disorders (such as Parkinson’s disease) or recent manipulation of the throat (general anesthesia, endoscopy, being placed on a ventilator). We need to pay more attention to swallowing problems.”
Particularly disturbing is the fact that as the population ages, the numbers of people residing in nursing homes and the burden of chronic disease will expand rapidly.
“If you think there’s a problem in hospitals, the nursing home statistics are even more shocking, I’m sure,” he said.
So why does the system break down? Brown says, for lots of reasons.
“Part of it is that doctors are too damn intimidating,” he said. “They snap at nurses. They don’t want to be called at night, which is particularly intimidating to nurses working the ‘third shift.’”
In addition, doctors can be hard to reach.
“And it’s not because they’re always on the golf course. Many are just working so hard, they can’t return every phone call immediately,” Brown said.
A dilemma for patients is their feeling powerless in hospitals — thus disenfranchising them from a right to offer input over their own life.
“What do we do when they get admitted? They are given a number,” Brown said. “Men and women are stripped of their clothes and many belongings. They are put in emasculating hospital gowns with their butts exposed while their docs saunter in, wearing their white coats or Brooks Brothers suits, with an attitude that if they stay a minute longer at your bedside, they are going to miss a plane.”
During Brown’s 20 years in practice there has been improvement in the area of patient safety, but much more work is needed, he said.
“I don’t know if we can make our doctors or nurses much smarter than they already are,” he said. “We are already tackling problems and curing diseases which would have been fatal when I graduated from Yale in 1981. The body of medical knowledge and new treatments continues to grow exponentially.”
The medical profession needs to use its knowledge and resources to put better checks and balances into the hospital system, Brown said.
“A gentle reminder from a 2001 Space Odyssey-style HAL computer might come in handy,” he mused. “‘Dave? Did you remember to give your patient a beta-blocker? Dave? Dave?’”
Diana Sevanian is a Signal staff writer. Her column appears Saturdays and she can be reached at [email protected].
