The Winner's Circle
The Sports Illustrated college football preview edition arrived in my mailbox last week, and if you know anything about me, you know what I did with it as well as my parakeet, who has enjoyed a more intimate view of it than I have.
It’s been two years since I fired my first shot from these pages about the problems inherent in college football — two years since I nailed my 99 thesis to the sports section telling you why I don’t like the sport.
Time has done little to soften my opinion of America’s most bloated pastime. If anything, my dislike for the sport has become more intense. My reasons — there were initially 10 — have multiplied.
No doubt you’re drowning in a sea of hype about the upcoming season. You may have dug out your old college pennant and you’re probably stockpiling chips and dip for Saturdays from here to 2005.
And as I do every year, I will attempt to rescue you from the mania. I will argue with you the demerits of this most tedious and inane of American sports.
Here are some reasons not to like college football. You’ll recognize some, but that’s intentional. If I can’t gain your allegiance through reason, perhaps I can win it by sheer force of redundancy.
1. The Ranking System(s)
I don’t care what new innovations the so-called experts plan to wreak upon the Bowl Championship Series (BCS) ranking system in 2004. It will never make sense.
I don’t really need to convince you of this do I? Not if you’re a USC fan (and I know many reemerged from the woodwork last year). What do you think about the ranking system that left Oklahoma in championship contention after they were embarrassed in the season’s final game?
How did you feel about watching LSU yuck it up on national television and claim that theirs was the true national championship?
2. Post-Season Folly
Until the NCAA post-season structure allows the best teams to settle matters on the field, I’ll never like college football.
I wrote two years ago that one day the BCS committee’s luck would run out and it happened last year, though the real loser was USC.
With so much debate and so much dissension over who was really number one, wouldn’t have made great sense to simply let the Tigers and Trojans play one more game?
I know, that was impossible under the current system and that’s why the system needs change. Not a tweak. Not a tune-up. It needs a complete overhaul.
Let the top eight teams play a three-round playoff. Start in mid-December and set the title game for New Year’s Day. You’d still have disputes, but at least they would surround teams ranked seven, eight and nine instead of one, two and three.
3. Overtime
The game unravels under the current overtime format. It devolves into some kind of Arena Football/Barnum and Bailey hybrid. Alternating possessions from the 25-yard line until someone runs out of breath? Why not just flip a coin and be done with it? Both are arbitrary but at least the coin flip is quick.
I prefer the dignity of the old format allowed — the heroic choice it gave coaches to go for the win. I’ll never forget Miami’s first championship. They won because then Nebraska coach Tom Osborne went for a two-point conversion and failed in the waning moments, rather than settle for a tie and leave the national title in the hands of — gasp — voters.
Osborne walked off the field on the short end of a one-point game, but the unapologetic look on his face as he left remains one of college football’s most enduring images.
4. The Criminal Element
Who exactly is playing college football these days? It used to be a student athlete had to attend class before he could take the field. But the game’s changed.
It’s a business now. Big-time money. Big-time contracts. Big-time pressure. Coaches do whatever it takes to win. They’ll recruit a kid with a rap sheet as long as the Gettysburg Address if it will net them two more W’s and a bowl game appearance.
Should we then be surprised by sexual scandals and thieving quarterbacks?
That’s actually become a guilty pleasure for me — waiting for the next college football scandal to break and then watching the coaches play the part of the shocked grandfather. “How could this happen,” they’ll gush out of one side of their mouths while out of the other they’re recruiting the next hoodlum for the defensive line.
There are many more reasons I could give not to like college football (and i have before). The never-ending season. The coporate logos. The wishbone. The lack of good non-conference matchups. The long halftimes. The growing insignificance of the once-proud Army-Navy game.
Not that it matters. Too many people like College football for any real change to occur. You and your buddies will still pitch in for the college football package on cable, right? You’ll still pour money into the sports bars each Saturday and you’ll love every minute of the debate over who’s number one.
But the game could be better and it should be better. And until it is, I’ll keep waving my flag.
In the meantime, my bird will remain the most informed college football pet this side of Happy Valley.
Bob Dickson’s column runs every Sunday in The Signal. He can be reached at [email protected]
