Two environmental watchdog groups have filed a lawsuit against the city of Santa Clarita over the approval of four auto dealerships in Valencia.
The Center for Biological Diversity and the Santa Clarita Organization for Planning the Environment filed a complaint in a Ventura County court Friday, accusing the city of skirting the state-mandated environmental process before it approved new dealerships in July.
The Newhall Land and Farming Co., which was named as a co-defendant, had asked the city for permission to construct four dealerships along Valencia Boulevard, in front of the Hart PONY Baseball and Softball fields. The council approved Newhall Land’s proposal with a 3-0 vote at a special meeting July 8.
The lawsuit alleges that several previously approved plans and environmental studies weren’t followed, and claims that the city never asked for new studies after the plans were changed.
Newhall Land spokeswoman Marlee Lauffer said the lawsuit has no merit.
“Unfortunately, what this lawsuit does is impact sales tax revenue to the city and hurt the over 4,000 kids that utilize the baseball fields,” Lauffer said.
The baseball and softball league would take possession of the ball fields, now owned by Newhall Land, as part of the auto dealership construction proposal.
Lauffer said her company will have to get final approval from the federal Wildlife Service and the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers before it would be able to move any dirt or begin construction.
“We have worked with the city and the Hart league to make the project a win-win for the entire community,” she said.
Mercedes Benz and Infiniti have expressed interest in locating dealerships on the property.
Car sales generate roughly 23 percent of the city’s sales tax revenue. In an attempt to protect one of its largest revenue generators, the City Council in May passed a resolution that calls for all car dealers to be centrally located around Creekside Road in Valencia.
City Attorney Carl Newton said he disagrees with the lawsuit’s claims.
“We responded to all the concerns at the (July 8) hearing,” Newton said.
Newton said he couldn’t make further comment because he didn’t receive the lawsuit until Monday afternoon.
The complaint alleges that the city failed to obey the California Environmental Quality Act after Newhall Land changed its original plans for the Valencia Boulevard frontage. Newhall Land’s North Valencia I master plan, approved by the city in 1997, called for a retail center instead of car dealerships.
“(T)he project at issue is significantly different, with different impacts, more severe impact and impacts that were not analyzed or studied in the 1997 (North Valencia I Environmental Impact Report),” the lawsuit alleges.
Kate Neiswender, attorney for the Center for Biological Diversity and for SCOPE, states in the complaint that Newhall Land was cleared in 1997 to move 324,000 cubic yards of fill dirt, instead of the 554,000 the company proposed with the new project.
Neiswender also states that no further studies were conducted after 1997 concerning the impact of placing auto-repair services next to the Santa Clara River. Nor did the 1997 plan mention moving water wells, or the impacts on the southwestern arroyo toad, a federally protected endangered species, the complaint states.
“We remain concerned that the city is glossing over findings of toads in the area,” said Peter Galvin, conservation biologist for the center. “The cumulative impacts are something that needs to be stressed.”
Galvin said the city is slowly deconstructing the river and is using the arroyo toad at its disposal.
“The city and other agencies are taking an ostrich-type view of this project,” he said.
In August 2000, the city and Newhall Land sent letters to the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service to request the arroyo toad be taken off the critical habitat list within city limits. The Fish and Wildlife service granted the request in February 2001.
Galvin said the city has used the toad and other environmental species as its main defense against the proposed Transit Mixed Concrete mine in eastern Soledad Canyon, but should use that same energy for all projects.
“We’re pleased the city recognizes the threat the TMC proposed to the river and its species,” Galvin said. “Unfortunately, we haven’t seen that same concern to the other planning decisions.”
