At a round table in the back of the Newhall Courthouse, rowdy teens tapped their braces and decided the fates of their classmates.
The presiding judge leaned over the bench in the courtroom Thursday and warned the five teenage defendants sitting below.
“You got caught and you’re fortunate you’re in this environment and not in front of me,” Judge Lloyd Nash said to the five teenage boys charged in the first Teen Court trial of the program’s 10th year. “In the real world of adult court, it’s a whole different ballgame.”
Sheriff’s deputies had arrested the teens after a midnight paintballing spree through a local neighborhood, during which the high school students splattered homes and cars with paint, causing about $4,000 in damage.
The boys admitted to the allegations, but wound up with a shot at striking it from their criminal records through the program offered by the city and sheriff’s department.
They would stand trial, but their identities would be protected, and, as the program’s judge pro-tem Jeff Armendariz said, the paperwork is shredded.
In Teen Court, high schoolers decide the punishments to fit the crimes of their peers.
“Why did you guys do it?” asked one juror. “Was it just for fun?”
A flurry of responses came from the five young defendants. They said they didn’t know the paint was permanent and they didn’t mean to cause damage.
“We thought it was, like, a harmless prank,” one of the four 15-year-old defendants said.
The lone 16-year-old said they just weren’t thinking.
Several cars had to be detailed and homes repaired. The boys all chipped in to pay the $4,000 in restitution to the randomly chosen victims. Some were working to repay their own parents, who had to foot the bill.
Their parents grounded them, and wrested away their cell phones and privileges. But on Thursday, the teens had to answer to a jury of their own.
Jested cruel and unusual punishments bounced around the deliberation chamber as the jurors and a teen mediator argued whether they were being too strict or too lenient.
“OK, all-American,” one juror snapped at another after a particularly harsh suggestion. “You never done nothin’ wrong?”
“I never got caught,” the teen responded.
The jury settled on at least 60 hours of community service for all of the defendants, service on five Teen Court juries, two-page essays, and an 8 p.m. curfew, two hours earlier than the curfew imposed by the city.
For three months of the six-month probation, the five will be banned from hanging out together outside of school.
The 16-year-old boy who drove around his four friends that night before he could legally drive passengers, was also sentenced to repeat driver’s education courses and perform 90 hours of community service. Another defendant was sentenced to perform 95 hours of community service because jurors saw him grinning during the proceedings.
But after all was said and done, the defendants didn’t complain.
“I think it’s an awesome program, instead of going to (the juvenile courthouse in) Sylmar,” a 15-year-old defendant said.
Another defendant’s parents agreed.
“I think it’s great,” a mother who refused to give her name said. “It gives them a chance to wash away one night’s stupidity.”
To be eligible for a trial in the Teen Court, sheriff’s Det. Dan Finn said the 13- to 17-year-old Santa Claritan offenders must be charged with crimes that aren’t violent nor gang related, and have no prior felony convictions.
