A proposition on the November ballot that would tax the wealthy to expand mental health services for all is a long-overdue “fix” for a serious social problem, the measure’s author said during a visit to the Santa Clarita Valley on Friday.
Assemblyman Darrell Steinberg, D-Sacramento, said it would help solve the decline in care for people with severe mental illness. That decline, he said, has led to a mushrooming of homelessness since the state began closing mental hospitals in the 1960s.
Passage of Prop. 63 “would be the fulfillment of a promise,” Steinberg said during a public forum in Saugus, “a promise that for 36 years has been abjectly unfulfilled.”
But one of the Santa Clarita Valley’s state assemblymen and its county supervisor have taken stands against the bill.
Assemblyman Keith Richman, R-Granada Hills, who is also a physician, acknowledged that the state needs better funding for its mental health care system, but said the state must also deal with other pressing issues.
A spokesman for Supervisor Michael D. Antonovich said the bill would be bad government.
“What’s needed is reform in financing for these services,” said spokesman Tony Bell. “Focusing on taxing one segment of the population and anticipating a stable source of funds is not a responsible policy.”
The Mental Health Services Act would impose a 1 percent tax on state residents earning more than $1 million per year, collecting upwards of $700 million for prevention and treatment programs.
The bill would prohibit the state from cutting mental health funding below current levels, and require the state to create prevention, early intervention and training programs. It would also fund county services and programs for mentally ill children and adults, overseen by a commission.
Steinberg appeared at the Child and Family Center in Saugus to campaign. His audience was largely composed of the center’s staff and board members.
The initiative stipulates that cities and non-profit organizations would only get funding if their programs demonstrate a track record of success, Steinberg said.
The center’s executive program services director cited an extreme example of how an individual problem can affect an entire community.
“If you’ve got a child who is so disturbed, they’d consider doing something like the kids did in Columbine, that’s going to affect more than that child and the child’s family,” Ari Levy said. “We have had such kids. We intervened on more than one occasion.”
He said more subtle examples of mental health issues — children who are depressed, anxious, disruptive at school or who have emotional and substance abuse disorders or have been abused — illustrate how helping the individual impacts the wider community.
There are “easily” three times as many children who need services as are currently being seen at the Center, Levy said. The center handles more than 500 cases each week, providing various types of service, he said.
The Child and Family Center has grown by 500 percent in the last five years, and has more than 100 names on its waiting list. The Center exports therapists to at least 22 school campuses in the Santa Clarita Valley.
The SCV is one of the fastest growing communities in the country, and is underfunded for the services it should be providing, Levy said. The bill would not replace other funding sources, it would supplement them.
Richman had cited other issues in California that need to be addressed — education, higher education, roads and infrastructure needs, and healthcare in general — and said the legislature and the governor will need to decide how to meet all of these needs.
Richman said he seeks alternatives and a more comprehensive solution than the bill. Viable solutions should address issues of the uninsured and the entire healthcare system “which is in crisis,” he said.
Antonovich also finds fault with the bill.
“This proposition gives false hope that by levying additional tax on millionaires,” said spokesman Bell. “California will have the revenue to do what is necessary to enhance mental health services.”
A legislative analyst said $275 million could be generated in 2004-05, $750 million in 2005-06, $800 million in 2006-07, with increases expected in coming years.
State and county programs would expand with the influx of funds. Costs for local municipalities and the state could decrease as county funding increases, which could total in the “low hundreds of millions of dollars annually.”
Richman and Joe Nation, D-Marin and Sonoma counties, will hold five town hall meetings and conferences in partnership with think-tank Rand Corp. and numerous universities, to discuss healthcare access and costs. The first meeting will be held at UCLA on Monday.
“Many people are working on the issues,” Richman said. “There will be broad participation from policymakers and experts in various fields. We’re hoping to introduce a bipartisan package of legislation to address the healthcare issue in California.”
