The city of Santa Clarita’s approach that annexations should be revenue-neutral, or better, is right on the money.
It’s quite a switch from the formative years of cityhood, when early city councils seemed to have an annex-at-all-costs stance. The city frequently expanded its borders at the expense of existing residents because it cost more to provide services to the new neighborhoods than they returned to the city’s tax base.
The old practice made some sense at the time. Our city mothers and fathers initially wanted to create a 90-square-mile city that encompassed the entire Santa Clarita Valley, so existing residents would have a greater say over land-use decisions in the undeveloped areas. But the Los Angeles County Local Agency Formation Commission, which controls new-city borders, bowed to the wishes of major property owners who didn’t want their development proposals to be decided by a new city council that was more likely to nix them than was the growth-happy county Board of Supervisors.
LAFCO trimmed the new city of Santa Clarita’s size to about 39.5 square miles, including most of the area that was already built up and leaving most of the undeveloped property in county hands. Santa Clarita’s early city councils naturally had a propensity to want to expand the city’s borders.
But that meant taking in residential areas only after their revenue-generating days were over — after they were developed and started incurring costs in the form of police, fire and other services.
Adding the new neighborhoods meant the city would have to allocate resources to serve them, without enough new tax dollars coming in to offset those services. The Valencia Northbridge community, for instance, added a few thousand residents to the city’s population figures, but it was a money-loser.
Over time the city expanded its borders to encompass 47.87 square miles, including the 265-home Wes Thompson Ranch, annexed to the city last month.
No more. Now, the city is developing guidelines to govern annexations to make sure they won’t be a burden to an ever-tightening city budget.
“The council wants a guide to annexations that are fiscally neutral,” said Planning Director Jeff Lambert, acknowledging that some of the city’s latest additions were financial burdens.
Four annexations that are in the works would expand the city by 1,600 acres, and one of them is Golden Valley Ranch, which could be a winner if its planned 600,000-square-foot commercial center adds an expected $1 million in tax revenues to the city’s tax kitty.
Given the city’s tight budget this year, it can’t afford any more money-losing annexations. The new approach is the fiscally prudent way to go.
