The multi-federal agency raid on the Keysor-Century Corp. in February was prompted in part by a lawsuit settled for a half-million dollars last year in which a former employee alleged the company had a computer program that automatically falsified air quality readings, The Signal has learned.
Santa Clarita resident Esteban Tubera, a one-time laboratory technician at Keysor’s Saugus plant, claimed the company participated in several illegal activities — including doctoring reports and releasing toxic and hazardous waste into the air and groundwater — in his wrongful termination lawsuit in May 2000. Keysor settled out-of-court with Tubera for $500,000 in May 2001, court papers show.
Based on statements from a “confidential ex-employee,” the Federal Bureau of Investigation, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and the Occupational Health and Safety Administration raided the plant Feb. 12 on suspicion that the company violated the Clean Water Act, Clean Air Act and Resource Conservation and Recovery Act, the warrant stated.
In his lawsuit against Keysor, Tubera claimed the company knowingly and intentionally altered air quality monitoring reports that were turned in to county, state and federal agencies. Tubera was fired from Keysor in November 1997.
Tubera’s attorney, Will Ramsey, said he couldn’t talk about the case because of a gag order placed on the May 2001 settlement agreement. Tubera couldn’t be reached for comment.
According to the complaint, Tubera said the company had a computer monitoring program that changed air quality readings.
“The (gas chromatograph) would analyze each sample in turn and feed the numeric result into a computer database table. The table would record the original emission entry. However, these original entries were later reviewed for excessive level readings, which were then altered to a random number within legal limits and printed in a summary report … The original magnetic table file would be overwritten, and all other papers containing the original emission data would be destroyed,” the lawsuit stated.
The case was settled before it could be determined in court whether the claims were accurate.
Steve Tekosky, an environmental attorney representing Keysor, wouldn’t comment on Tubera’s claims, but did say the company hasn’t done anything wrong.
“The company was in compliance (with state and federal agencies) before and after the raid,” Tekosky said.
The EPA issued a 30-day compliance letter to Keysor on April 3 telling the company to comply with air emission regulations or it would be forced to cease operations. Keysor remains in operation today.
“It is our position that the (EPA) order was unnecessary because it was in compliance before the order,” Tekosky said.
A statement from the EPA dated April 3 says, “Keysor reports indicate the company had been exceeding emissions for the past 12 months.”
Several allegations made by FBI Special Agent Kathleen J. Giles in an affidavit echo the claims made by Tubera in his lawsuit against Keysor.
Giles’ affidavit says reports from a confidential ex-employee caused her to begin investigating the company, and that she witnessed several violations personally. She had been investigating the company since December 2000, the affidavit states.
“Evidence shows that Keysor management personnel including (President) Howard Hill, (Plant Manager) Scott Speakman and (Plant Foreman) Frank Celeya instructed and/or knew of the continuous falsification of environmental exposure and emissions data that were submitted to local, state and federal regulatory agencies,” Giles’ affidavit states.
Giles couldn’t be reached Friday for comment, but FBI spokesman Matt McLaughlin said that since the issue is still under investigation, no new information or a record of what was seized during the raid could be released.
U.S. Assistant Attorney Joseph Johns wouldn’t comment on the investigation or the likelihood of arrests.
However, Johns told The Signal in a Feb. 14 interview that, “It’s fair to say that employees in a management position (who) had responsibility and authority over the area of the equipment which are the subject of this investigation will face possible arrest and indictment.”
Johns added that all agencies involved have a vested interest in facilitating the investigation.
“If there was ever a case we needed to move on quickly, this would be one of them,” he said, because it “concerns exposure of employees to substances such as vinyl chloride, which have very toxic effects on the human body. It’s the type of conduct which, if truly going on, we want to stop right away.”
Tubera’s lawsuit claimed that personnel monitoring reports were falsified. The lawsuit said that each Keysor employee is required to be tested quarterly to gauge emission exposure. Federal and state regulations stipulate that employees not be subjected to emission levels in excess of 1 part per million of emissions averaged over an eight-hour period, or a level in excess of 5 parts per million in any 15-minute period.
A monitoring device worn by the employee is analyzed by the gas chromatograph and a readout is printed, from which the vinyl chloride emission result is obtained, the claim stated.
The lawsuit said: “This result is then entered into a personnel monitoring vinyl chloride chart containing the results for several employees. This preliminary chart is then shown to the supervisor, who orders the alteration of any reading in excess of legal action limits, and the final numbers are then keypunched into a different database, which is kept as the only available evidence of the monitoring results. The original (gas chromatograph) graphs and the interim report are then destroyed … However, since the monitoring results are altered, the employees were, and still are, defrauded into enduring unknown health risks, including the very real risk of contracting cancer, from exposure to excessive level of the carcinogen vinyl chloride.”
Keysor’s History
Keysor-Century was founded by James B. “Bud” Keysor in 1946 and has remained a family business since. Keysor’s five children and their spouses remain in control of the company today. James Keysor died in May 2000.
The facility moved to its current location in the 26000 block of Springbrook Avenue, east of San Fernando Road and off Drayton Street, in the 1950s.
The company began by manufacturing plastic products, ultimately turning its focus on vinyl records, floor tiles, credit cards and plastic bottles.
A variety of chemicals are used to make the products, including vinyl chloride and polyvinyl chloride, which have been proven as carcinogens. Vinyl chloride is a colorless, highly flammable gas that causes risks to anyone who inhales its fumes.
Those fumes are what prompted the 1977 closure of Saugus Elementary School, which was located across the street from the plant and now houses a shopping center.
James Keysor’s son-in-law, Howard Hill, ran much of the operation until his August 2001 death. The company is now run by Robert Keysor, James’ son.
Shortly after the February raid, the company filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection. Bankruptcy court papers show the company made more than $50 million in gross sales revenue in 2000.
There are more than 1,300 creditors listed under the filing. The company is scheduled to go before Judge Arthur Greenwald in U.S. Bankruptcy Court on Nov. 20.
Several members of the Keysor board of directors have quit, company attorney Bob Crockett said. One of them quit the day of the raid, he added. None have been fired, but mostly family members remain on the board.
Potential Health Impacts
Vinyl chloride and polyvinyl chloride have been recognized as carcinogens and can cause a variety of cancers that appear in various body organs. These include brain, lung and liver cancer, Renauds Syndrome, lymphoma and leukemia.
According to Alise Cappel, research director for the Center for Environmental Health, the side effects from the chlorides have both short- and long-term impacts.
“The gas is a constant threat to the environment and to the health of the community,” Cappel said.
Once the chemical or its vapors have entered the body, the residue can be detected in blood, urine and breast milk.
Two of the most commonly found diseases are Renauds Syndrome, hardening of body tissue, and acroostedysis, deterioration of the bones within the hand. Acroostedysis is more commonly found among workers who touch and clean the lining of chemical tanks.
Cappel said the danger with the chlorides comes when they are heated and turn into liquid form, then into a gaseous state, which can be smelled but not seen.
Since Keysor is in the middle of bankruptcy proceedings, the court set a “claims bar date,” a deadline for all claims to be filed against the company, for June 30. No more lawsuits, including health or wrongful termination claims, can be filed against the company unless Judge Greenwald overturns the deadline that expired six weeks ago.
A search of county court files indicates there are no such cases pending against Keysor.
Johanna Congleton, public health associate with the Los Angeles-based advocacy group Physicians for Social Responsibility, said hundreds of Santa Clarita residents are potentially affected by Keysor-Century.
“The community has the right to know what it’s being exposed to,” Congleton said.
Physicians for Social Responsibility has been monitoring the health cases that could be related to the Keysor plant. Congleton said the company only has to provide public notification to people who were living or working immediately near the plant.
“We need to give documentation to the wider community about what is going on over there,” she said.
However, Congleton said there is limited data on what sort and amount of contamination may exist.
“Unfortunately, there’s not a lot of data available for public release because of the ongoing investigation,” she said. “We don’t really have the correct and accurate data to make an assessment on how the wider community is impacted.”
Signal intern Heather Powell and City Editor Leon Worden contributed to this report.
