I’ll never forget the editorial cartoon my friend Randy Wicks drew in 1994, two years before he died. Check that — Randy drew many cartoons I’ll never forget. But this week, I was reminded of one in particular.
It’s a two-frame job (shown at right), and the first box shows a smiling man peeking out from behind a shower curtain, with a towel hanging on the rack and a washer and dryer waiting next to the shower stall, presumably containing freshly washed, clean clothes.
It’s a picture of some of the most basic requirements of human dignity.
That first frame, with the freshly shampooed gentleman who’s about to towel off, is captioned, “Shower and laundry for homeless offered by the Interfaith Council.”
The second frame is captioned, “Shower and laundry for homeless offered by the City Council.”
It shows the same guy, dirty and shivering, standing in the rain under a dark cloud as a bar of soap is tossed at him.
Interesting. A decade later, and we’ve come full circle on that study in contrasts.
Subsequent to that 1994 cartoon, the City Council did come around, and the local effort to provide shelter to the homeless evolved from an uphill battle by the Interfaith Council — a coalition of local religious organizations — to a cooperative effort involving the city of Santa Clarita and the Santa Clarita Community Development Corp.
The CDC is a nonprofit organization formed for the specific purpose of assisting the local homeless.
For the past seven years running, the CDC has operated winter homeless shelters on sites provided by the city. However, that apparently will come to an end this year: The city is keeping its promise to residents who live near the Via Princessa Metrolink station, but coming up short on its pledge to find a new location for the shelter.
You see, last year the City Council told residents the winter of ’04 would be the final year for the shelter to be located at Via Princessa. Fingers were poked into the air, the good ol’ Santa Clarita “can-do” spirit was invoked, and the challenge was embraced to find a suitable, more permanent shelter location.
A year later, and we... got... nuttin’.
It’s not that the will doesn’t exist locally to help the homeless. It does — of course, so long as it’s the women, children and “families” we’re helping. To hear the rhetoric, if you’re a single male who’s down on his luck, well, to hell with you.
Regardless, the willingness is there to provide a shelter. The City Council is willing to provide a matching grant. The Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors this week indicated it’s willing to help, too, and has asked county homeless services officials to wade in. The CDC, of course, stands at the ready, with the resources and manpower to operate the shelter and help the Santa Clarita Valley’s homeless stay out of the cold.
Just one thing: There’s no place to put the shelter.
Amazing how tiny details can gum up the works.
It’s certainly easy enough to understand how we got here. Truth of the matter is, all benevolence aside, most people don’t want a homeless shelter plopped into the middle of their neighborhood. While we all may be willing to chip in a few bucks, and the better folks among us are even willing to give some of their time ladling soup into bowls for people who otherwise wouldn’t get a hot meal, we’ll still be a lot more comfortable if the homeless shelter is Not In My Back Yard.
I know a local Democrat or two who just might lynch me for this, but here goes: I readily admit I’m no better at solving this problem than anyone else, and you can go right ahead and count me as one of those NIMBY’s.
I don’t want a homeless shelter in my back yard, either.
What is your single biggest investment? If you own a home, there’s a pretty good chance that’s it.
Wanting to protect that investment doesn’t make you a bad person. And, even if you sincerely believe the shelter will not have a material impact on issues like crime, there’s a pretty legitimate property value question.
Suppose you’re a home buyer, and while on your way to view a potential purchase, you notice that it’s just a couple of blocks from the neighborhood homeless shelter.
Are you offering top dollar for that house?
Of course not. So it’s not fair to label people as insensitive louts due to the simple fact that they want the homeless shelter in another part of town.
Which, of course, brings us back to the same question with which we’ve wrestled, as a community, for the past decade. Most compassionate local folks believe we should do something to help shelter homeless people who already are in our community.
But where?
There’s a fair amount of debate over the “migrating” homeless who might only come here if we have a shelter — it’s the old, “build it, they will come” argument, and it does have some validity.
But putting that aside for now, the fact remains, we as a community have failed, after 10 years, to figure out how we will assist our less fortunate neighbors during the winter’s longest, coldest nights.
There is talk of city matching grants if a shelter location is found, and, failing that, motel vouchers for homeless families. But through all that talk remains the fact that we haven’t solved the problem.
A decade later, and it’s come full circle: We’re this close to tossing a bar of soap out into the rain.
Tim Whyte is The Signal’s general manager.
