Are you a racist?
We asked the question this week as a result of reports of racial tensions at a local high school. The question was posed on The Signal’s Web site, where readers can click on their responses, and the answers are tallied on the online “Reader Meter.”
This week’s tally?
Racists, 738.
Non-racists, 477.
What do you make of that? Does the anonymity of an online poll allow people to be honest about their true feelings? Or are people manipulating the vote by clicking “yes” even if they’re members of the Rainbow Coalition?
It was an eyebrow-raising question to ask. Its answers followed suit.
The issue of race relations had been under the radar lately in the Santa Clarita Valley, until a parent and her daughter went to the William S. Hart Union High School District board and testified about on-campus racial issues.
Our valley is becoming increasingly diverse, but the issues themselves aren’t completely new. My high school wasn’t exactly a picture of racial strife, but occasionally tension would surface. Saugus High School in the early-1980s — stop doing the math, please — was the prototypical SCV high school: Mostly white, middle- to upper-middle-class kids, and a lot of transplants from the “other” valley whose families came here in search of a better quality of life than what they’d have down south.
They did find it.
The SCV then was less cosmopolitan than now. There was no mall, agriculture was a for-profit business in the heart of the valley and our town was on the verge of unprecedented growth.
My high school wasn’t what you would call “diverse.” I did have black friends, Latino friends and Asian friends (one of whom famously referred to himself an “Ornamental”). But the campus was almost all white.
There was racial conflict sometimes. I remember there being an occasional brawl, with participants divided along racial lines — usually white versus Hispanic. But on the whole, high school here was a relatively peaceful experience, in which kids of different backgrounds for the most part got along.
I suspect some of that has not changed; it’s not like we’re having race riots on campus every day. Yet it doesn’t surprise me to hear the claims of racial tensions at Valencia High School — and I’d be no more surprised if I were to hear of similar occurrences at other schools.
For starters, kids can be mean. And beyond that, they inherit prejudices from mom and dad.
Here’s what happened this month: A Valencia High School parent and student went before the school board voicing concerns about what they say is a trend of racial abuse by students. “Kids are calling other kids ‘n-----,’ and taunt(ing) them,” said Yetunde Alabi, a Valencia honor student and founder of the school’s Black Student Union.
It’s a club. Based on race.
Does anyone else wonder whether that might promote racial tensions rather than harmony?
Imagine the fallout if there were something called the “White Student Union.” Omigosh. That wouldn’t last five minutes before being branded as the second coming of the KKK.
But it’s deemed socially and politically acceptable to have a Black Student Union and, one would presume, a student union representing the unique needs and interests of any other ethnic group, so long as it’s not white.
It doesn’t occur for a second to the backers of an ethnic club that forming such an organization is, inherently, racist. That doesn’t justify abusive behavior in any way, but it should come as no surprise if the formation of a Black Student Union stokes tensions rather than relieving them.
I won’t stand here on my soapbox and claim to know what it’s like to be black. I don’t. Nor will I claim to have the solution to these kinds of problems. I don’t. But I know this: The problem isn’t the school’s problem. It’s all of ours.
The school doesn’t turn kids into bigots. Yes, schools should (and, do) deal with kids who conduct themselves inappropriately, and there’s a place for discipline when kids treat each other in unacceptable ways. The schools, though, are not causing the situation.
Our community is changing. This isn’t Mayberry anymore. Some might say we need to promote tolerance — but I hate the phrase “tolerance” because it implies that something is to be endured, rather than embraced.
So where do we register on the harmony meter?
Ask 1,000 people in person if they are racists, and 999 will say, “No,” because at some level, everyone knows it’s wrong to judge people based on the color of their skin. Ask the same question in an anonymous forum, and the results, for one reason or another, are quite different.
If nothing else, the concerns raised by Yetunde Alabi forced SCV residents to think about our increasing diversity, and our community’s racial harmony — or the need to strive for it.
Alabi’s voice also forced introspection for a lot of people, who are privately pondering the question:
Are you a racist?
Tim Whyte is The Signal’s general manager. His column appears Sundays.
