A countywide homeless services agency Friday declined to fund a winter shelter in Sylmar that was set to house Santa Clarita’s homeless people. The agency will reconsider its decision in two weeks — during which city and county officials were strongly urged to devise a local shelter plan.
Commissioners from the Los Angeles Homeless Services Authority voted 4-3 against a proposal to fund the temporary winter shelter at the Sylmar Armory, one vote short of the number required for passage.
“I’m very disappointed over LAHSA’s decision today,” said Raine Ritchey, policy deputy for Supervisor Michael D. Antonovich, whose office helped to underwrite the program. “We feel this proposal was win-win for everyone. I felt the decision was made to punish the city of Santa Clarita at the expense of the most vulnerable population, which is the homeless.”
The Armory was not due to open this winter, in lieu of a more permanent shelter solution. It is not feasible to operate the shelter for fewer than 125 homeless occupants. LAHSA had funded L.A. Family Housing’s year-round shelter program, with a total of 80 beds, and agreed to fund its winter shelter that would serve 45 people.
Antonovich brokered the deal to open the Armory on Dec. 16. — provided beds were made available to 40 homeless Santa Claritans. The gap between paying for 85 and 125 beds was closed by funds supplied by Antonovich. Unless the commissioners change their minds, it will not open.
“I was surprised (by LAHSA’s decision),” said Jerome Nilssen, project director for L.A. Family Housing, in North Hollywood. The organization has operated a winter shelter at the Armory for many years.
“We have 45 beds,” he said. Cots are set up in the facility’s cafeterias. “If anyone from Santa Clarita gets here, that’s fine. They’ll have to compete with homeless people from the San Fernando Valley.”
L.A. Family Housing serves a broad swath of territory in the Valley — from West Hills to Woodland Hills, and Pacoima to Sunland.
The commissioners said Santa Clarita officials have been too responsive to critics, and not cognizant enough of their responsibility to provide services for the homeless.
Nilssen said precautions have been taken to avoid loitering around the North Hollywood facility, which is in a “more or less a residential area.”
Commissioner Sarah Dusseault said Santa Clarita could demand standards of behavior and operation, such as no walk-ins, hiring a security guard and an entrance that is not visible from the street.
“I feel like Santa Clarita never looked at (the options) as a possibility,” she said.
Mayor Bob Kellar said the Council has been “verbally assaulted on an annual basis for and against” issues involving homeless people, so it sought a new model as a solution.
City Manager Ken Pulskamp said an “intense public outcry,” came from condominium residents near the Via Princessa location, centering around “crime, protection of children and (decreased) property values.”
When pressed about actionable instances, Pulskamp said homeowners testified to them at City Council meetings.
Santa Clarita Management Analyst Dennis Luppens said late Friday that since 1997, $223,000 has been paid to the Santa Clarita Community Development Corporation or to companies who provided the modular shelter units. That sum does not include staff time.
Los Angeles City Councilwoman Jan Perry scolded Santa Clarita officials.
“I do not think cities should be able to opt out,” she said. “We (need to) start from the perspective that ‘these folks’ are here, and we’re going to have to deal with them. Whether we get re-elected (or not), on some issues you have to make a moral decision where you’re going to go to begin the negotiation. We can’t support plans that force people out of their communities and into dangerous situations.”
Representatives from the offices of Los Angeles City Councilmen Alex Padilla and Antonio Villagarosa and Los Angeles Mayor James Hahn were also against the proposal. Hahn voiced his views to Kellar on Thursday.
“It’s the difference between shipping your grandmother off to a convalescent hospital when you have a 6-bedroom house,” said Armen Ross, Hahn’s director of homeless services. “Moving people from one end of the county to another city is not reasonable.”
The Armory program was part of an arrangement between Lutheran Social Services of Southern California and L.A. Family Housing, which provides numerous homeless programs. LSS had won a contract with the city of Santa Clarita to furnish case management and referral services. Antonovich’s office asked LAHSA to work with LSS to also facilitate winter shelter services.
The commissioners sought testimony from Mark Young, vice president of the nonprofit SCCDC. The SCCDC has provided temporary winter shelter in Santa Clarita for the past seven seasons. They pointedly asked him how much time and money it would take to reassemble the modular unit. Young said it would take between four and six weeks.
Ritchey said Antonovich will hold a meeting within the next two weeks following up on the matters discussed, and a number of speakers from today’s meeting said they plan to show up at Santa Clarita’s City Council meeting on Dec. 14 to address the Council to offer suggestions and offer their expertise in dealing with the issue.
Questions were floated about Antonovich securing a site for a shelter on county-owned land in an unincorporated area near the city. After the meeting, Pulskamp said he hoped Antonovich would be successful in using the power of his office to help site a shelter in the SCV.
When LAHSA meets again, it could approve the proposal that was on the table today, formulate a different set of conditions or veto the measure again.
When Commissioner Owen Newcomer asked if the proposal is approved, what assurance the commission would have the city would not come back with the same answer next year, Kellar said he could not guarantee a result, “but we will make the best effort.”
