Firms representing mining, construction and transportation industries have thrown in their lots with Cemex in the legal battle with Santa Clarita over a proposed giant open-pit mine in Soledad Canyon.
The Southern California Rock Products Association and the California Mining Association say a shortage of concrete and aggregate looms, and the 78-million-ton mine is necessary to meet construction needs in the future.
“This project has garnered the attention of these national groups,” Cemex spokeswoman Sarah Simpson said Thursday. “It’s a very important project to community, state and national organizations.”
The Rose Institute and the Rand Corp., research and public policy organizations, have concluded there is ample aggregate and no shortage.
Although it lost a battle in federal court, the city has kept up pressure against the mine and has sued the county, alleging its Board of Supervisors violated state environmental protection laws by approving the mining operation. The suit seeks to halt the project.
Santa Clarita will file a reply brief, said attorney Geralyn Skapik.
Skapik said the groups, which filed “friend-of-the-court” briefs supporting the federal court settlement agreement and consent decrees signed by Cemex, have a financial interest in the outcome.
Besides Southern California Rock Products and California Mining Association, filers of “friends of the court briefs” with the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals included the American Road and Transportation Builders Association, Portland Cement Association, American Pavement Association, and Ready Mixed Concrete Association.
Among the local, regional and statewide organizations who have filed amicus briefs in support of the city’s appeal are state Attorney General Bill Lockyer’s office, the California Association of Realtors, the Newhall County Water District, the William S. Hart Union High School District, the Sierra Club, Santa Clarita Organization for Planning the Environment, the Santa Clarita Chamber of Commerce and the cities of Palmdale and Lancaster.
The Department of the Interior has licensed mineral rights to Cemex for the property, which the city of Santa Clarita purchased earlier this year. However, owning the land cannot halt the mine. The Bureau of Land Management has issued mining permits for the property.
In April 2002, the Board of Supervisors voted unanimously to deny Cemex a permit for its proposed project and issued a 35-page report enumerating the flaws in the developer’s environmental impact report. Cemex filed a federal lawsuit before the board’s denial was issued, but that did not alter the 5-0 vote against the project.
The city of Santa Clarita twice tried to intervene as an interested party in the federal suit, but was not permitted to do so by the trial judge, who determined the county would adequately represent the city’s interests.
But the city appealed, and a three-judge panel in San Francisco granted the city the right to intervene. By that time, however, Cemex and the county were nearing a settlement.
The resulting consent decree issued in federal court last March did not recognize the city as an intervener, Skapik said.
As agreed in the consent decree, county supervisors then approved Cemex’s environmental documents and permits on a 3-2 vote, with Supervisors Michael D. Antonovich and Zev Yaroslavsky dissenting.
