There are at least two sides to every story, and in the case of annexation, many more than two.
On the surface, it might seem simple. Which governmental entity is likely to provide the highest caliber of services for the (tax) money: the city of Santa Clarita or the county?
If you're already a Santa Clarita resident, you might have trouble deciphering what all the fuss is about. You've got a few more sheriff's deputies per capita than the people in the unincorporated county areas, and when you've got a gripe, you can take it right down the street to City Hall instead of waiting for a response from the Board of Supervisors 35 miles away. Who wouldn't want to join you?
But if you live in Stevenson Ranch or Westridge or Castaic, you might see it altogether differently. Your supervisor's local deputies are only a phone call away; how dare that upstart, too-big-for-its-britches city across the highway pick off parts of your community?
Community. It's a big deal - even more so, in some ways, west of Interstate 5 than in the separate enclaves of Newhall, Saugus, Canyon Country and "old" Valencia, which joined forces 17 years ago to create a new identity.
Many Stevenson Ranch and Castaic residents fear they'll lose their sense of community if Santa Clarita muscles its way in and takes them over. With Santa Clarita trying to cross the freeway and take the Valencia Commerce Center, is it any wonder the Castaic Area Town Council is preparing to stake out its territory with signs that read, "Welcome to Castaic" - including one directly in front of the Commerce Center?
Of course, city officials say they aren't muscling anybody or taking anybody over. Rather, they're responding to requests from businesses in the Commerce Center and property owners west of the freeway who want what the city has to offer.
For some of those businesses, it's a straightforward matter of dollars and sense. Join the city, and you'll escape the county's 5-percent tax on utilities. If you're a company that uses a lot of electricity in your manufacturing process, it adds up.
But not all businesses are on the same page. We know of businesses on the city side of the freeway whose only memorable contacts with City Hall have been negative, generally pertaining to the enforcement of codes.
And some critics see a double standard. Why does the city hold the opinions of "joiner" property owners paramount, while dismissing the wishes of property owners involved in the 5,800-home Las Lomas development?
Then, too, some fear the city might sell the farm in return for a west-side toehold. Case in point, Warner Bros.' Lyon Canyon Ranch.
Warner Bros. and its home-building partner, a division of D.R. Horton, took their development plans to Supervisor Mike Antonovich in the 1990s. Antonovich had a problem with the removal of so many hundreds of oak trees, and with a higher population density than the county's General Plan would allow.
So, Horton brought its proposal to the city of Santa Clarita and dangled the carrot of annexation in its covetous face.
City officials would argue that they won't hand the developer anything on a platter. The project will go through a public process, and the community, including west-side residents, will have many opportunities to opine on the oaks, the density, and the roads, schools and parks that would be needed - so that in the end, it will be a project that both the developer and the community at large can live with.
Just look at Golden Valley Ranch, they'd say, as an example of the city working to create a beneficial project on the county side of the line.
In the case of the Commerce Center, however, the annexation discussion may prove moot.
The Newhall Land and Farming Co. did a very clever thing when it started selling industrial and commercial property west of the freeway in the last decade or so. It placed deed restrictions on most of the parcels, reserving the annexation decision to itself.
Much like an early property owner probably kept the mineral rights beneath your home, Newhall Land made sure it retained the right to "vote" on annexing to Santa Clarita, or joining a second city, even after it sold the land.
Why? You'd have to ask Newhall Land for an official answer, but conventional wisdom dictates the company wants no interference with its future - the 21,000-home Newhall Ranch development. Give the city of Santa Clarita inroads west of the freeway, and LAFCO would have a tough time precluding it from gaining any official influence over the project.
Nor would Newhall Land want a second city to exert such influence. It's doing just fine in the unincorporated county, thank you very much.
What's best for the Santa Clarita Valley? It's a matter of opinion. As we said at the outset, there are many sides to the annexation issue, and we've only touched on a few of them here.
We are one valley with many different visions. But we've got time. Here at The Signal, we're committed to devoting as many news and opinion pages to the issue as it takes to reach accord.
That's what we'd really like to see in the coming year: meaningful dialogue. The city and county work together well in many areas, but on the subject of annexation, it's like they're speaking in different tongues.
Let's change that. As 2005 dawns, let's try to listen to each other and really hear.
