Henry Mayo Newhall Memorial Hospital ranked in the top 50 percent of hospitals nationwide in three categories including heart attacks, heart failure and pneumonia care, according to a federal report.
The report released on the Web site of Centers for Medicare and Medicaid revealed that Newhall Memorial scored in the top 10 percent of hospitals under key indicators relating to heart attack care.
The hospital received a top 50 percent rating for an indicator under heart failure care and two out of three indicators under pneumonia care.
Under the same category, the hospital scored in the top 10 percent under oxygen assessment and the top 50 percent under initial antibiotic timing. Also under the same category, pneumococcal vaccination documentation did not receive the 50 percent ranking.
“On the whole report, (pneumococcal vaccination) is the only area where we were not estimated in the 50 percent,” said Newhall Memorial spokeswoman Andie Bogdan. “That’s a challenge all of us will have to overcome; it’s an information retrieval challenge.”
Hospitals participating in the report conduct their own research on the topics and submit them to the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid for analysis. The pool of patients used in the current study includes senior citizens — a group representing 15 percent of patients at Newhall Memorial, according to Bogdan.
“(Senior citizens) use the hospitals the most,” Bogdan said. “Not only is their use of hospitals higher, the older you are the longer you are in the hospitals.”
Although the rankings at the local hospital varied, the statistics were not complete under four specific sub-categories a due to an insufficient amount of participants in the pool of hospital patients. The results might have also been skewed because of the new guidelines of the report that did not include some recent medicines used by Newhall Memorial, said Terry Stone, director of quality and medical staff for the hospital.
“The report gives us the ability to have comparative data,” Stone said. “We look at our own data and share it with our medical staff particularly our strength and areas we see as a concern; you can compare yourself to any hospital in the country.”
The agency released the report on Dec. 24 after the center, along with national hospital organizations and additional organizations, volunteered to submit data in order to monitor the quality of care in hospitals nationwide. More than 4,000 hospitals submitted information since November 2003 to be used in the study.
“Medicare is working with hospitals to measure quality that is meaningful and relevant; it’s a work in progress,” Bogdan said. “The next challenge is letting the public know what (the data) mean.”
The report, which reveals the performance of hospitals between January and March of 2004, allows hospitals to compare their performance with other facilities across the nation at the center’s Web site.
Representatives at Newhall Memorial said they prefer to compare the results to 14 hospitals in Southern California with similar demographics to the Santa Clarita Valley.
“We definitely benefit from looking at (the study),” Bogdan said. “We have a strategic goal of being in the top 25 percent in everything we do. We like to see that we’re in the top 10 percent and we’d like to stay there.”
Now, with the information made available to the public, the only concern of those in the medical profession is the ability of the average citizen to interpret the information for use.
“Unless you’re an expert in heart disease, it can be difficult to know what (the report) means as a consumer and as a patient,” Bogdan said. “The main thing is that they’re getting consistent data from hospitals that is now being reported on a quarterly basis. And that’s an important part of the process.”
