Elected officials are required by law to hold public hearings. But do they have to listen?
I can’t think how many times we’ve sent a cub reporter to downtown Los Angeles to cover the Board of Supervisors, only to have him or her return to the newsroom with tales of astonishment.
Somebody will be testifying, and the supervisors will be talking to each other, or getting up and wandering around, or shuffling papers — anything but listening to the constituent who’s exercising his constitutional right to state his case.
“How can they do that?”
Santa Clarita’s city councilors and planning commissioners are downright genteel by comparison. With one or two notable exceptions over the years, at least they feign attentiveness when one resident after another takes the microphone.
Even the complete wack jobs receive every courtesy. Sure, there was one time last year our now-mayor lost his cool and lowered himself to a particularly pugnacious attacker’s level — but only after sitting relatively still during the speaker’s allotted three minutes.
Folks in Los Angeles evidently don’t get the same courtesy.
I’m referring not to the Board of Supervisors, but rather to the meddlesome body that made such a stink last month about the way we neophytes conduct our municipal affairs — the Los Angeles City Council.
On Thursday, a three-judge panel from the state’s 2nd District Court of Appeal whopped the L.A. City Council upside the head, telling the 15 self-absorbed mucky-mucks that they need to listen when their lowly constituents are addressing them during a public hearing.
In perfect poetic justice, it was an East L.A. strip club that brought the L.A. City Council to its jurisprudential knees.
The date was June 13, 2003. It was Hawaiian shirt day for the City Council, and many were dressed accordingly.
(An aside to Santa Clarita spokesmaven Gail Ortiz: The Angelenos call us quirky? I think the closest we came to this was when Cameron Smyth and Frank Ferry bet on the Hart-Valencia game, the loser wearing the winner’s school colors.)
Anyway, the Blue Zebra wanted to extend its hours so its live nude pole dancers could start strutting their stuff at 11 a.m. instead of 6 p.m., and knock off at 4 a.m. instead of 2 a.m. on Fridays, Saturdays and Sundays.
L.A.’s code enforcers were keen to the idea, but the city’s planning commission said no.
The Blue Zebra appealed to the City Council, which sided with the planners and vetoed the nightclub’s application.
The Blue Zebra sued.
It didn’t argue the council’s right to say no. Rather, it accused the council of failing to give it a fair and impartial hearing.
Oh, a hearing was held, all right. But the council members weren’t listening.
As evidence, the Blue Zebra’s lawyers introduced a videotape they’d made of the hearing.
“The tape shows that when the council president summoned (a Blue Zebra representative) to the speaker’s lectern to present its case, eight council members — three of whom were absent — were not in their seats,” court records show. “Only two council members were visibly paying attention. Four others might have been paying attention, although they engaged themselves with other activities, including talking with aides, eating, and reviewing paperwork.”
From there, things devolved.
“One minute into (the Blue Zebra’s) presentation, a council member began talking on his cell phone and two council members, one of whom had been paying attention when the hearing opened, started talking to each other. A minute later, two other council members struck up their own private conversation.”
But fair’s fair, apparently, in L.A. politics. When the Blue Zebra’s opponents took the podium, they got equal maltreatment from the council.
In its defense, the city of Los Angeles told the court the hearing was indeed fair, because the council treated both sides the same.
Superior Court Judge David Yaffe — familiar to Santa Claritans for his weird rulings, like the one that said the Castaic Lake Water Agency can own, but not operate, the Santa Clarita Water Co. — sided with the Los Angeles City Council.
The Blue Zebra appealed, arguing before the appellate court that the law gives it — and its opponents — “the right to be equally heard, not equally ignored.”
The appellate panel overturned Yaffe’s decision and ordered the council to hold a new hearing.
“A fundamental principle of due process is, ‘he who decides must hear,’” the judges ruled. “The inattentiveness of council members during the hearing prevented the council from satisfying that principle.”
Elected officials must listen during public hearings, the court held, because they “(sit) in a quasi-judicial role, adjudicating the administrative appeal of constituents. ... Sitting as judges in the (Blue Zebra’s hearing), the council was obligated to pay attention.”
Incredibly, some of L.A.’s municipal leaders said they’d fight the appellate ruling.
Only in L.A.
Let’s keep it that way.
Leon Worden is The Signal’s opinion and multimedia editor. His column represents his own views, and not necessarily those of The Signal.
