The Castaic Lake Water Agency is asking a state appeals court to overturn a ruling that forbids the agency from owning a local water company.
Los Angeles County Superior Court Judge David Yaffe ruled in June that the water wholesaler was illegally operating the Santa Clarita Water Co., even though a law passed in October allowed the company to do so. However, the group that filed the lawsuit has several deal points, which if met, will drop the case.
“We hope the appeals court will see our side of it,” CLWA General Manager Dan Masnada said.
Masnada said the judge misinterpreted the legislation drafted to allow the agency to operate as a water retailer.
Assembly Bill 134 was drafted specifically for CLWA by San Diego Assemblyman David Kelley to allow the agency to purchase Santa Clarita Water and sell water at retail prices.
The bill was submitted to the Assembly in January 2001. CLWA purchased Santa Clarita Water in September 1999 for $63 million.
Yaffe gave CLWA until Sept. 16 to cease operations of Santa Clarita Water.
A group of activists brought the lawsuit against CLWA, claiming the company overstepped its authority when it purchased Santa Clarita Water because the agency is the Santa Clarita Valley’s sole water wholesaler.
Newhall County Water District board members Lynne Plambeck and Joan Dunn, along with former Santa Clarita City Councilwoman Jill Klajic and resident Jackie Bettencourt, filed the lawsuit in August 1999, before the sales transaction was completed.
Plambeck said the appeal is just CLWA’s way of getting around the rules.
“They didn’t want to obey the law the first time,” she said.
In a letter to the CLWA board of directors, the plaintiffs gave the agency several options to stave off any more actions in the case. Among some of the options, is to have CLWA separate its bank accounts and legal representation from Santa Clarita Water, and to have separate officers represent the two firms.
“We just want to make sure they’re operating at an arms length,” Plambeck said.
No court date has been set.
