Members of the Newhall County Water District board are split on whether the Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors should follow a Public Works Department recommendation and appoint former member Valerie Thomas to a recently vacated seat on the water board.
James Noyes, director of the Department of Public Works, was asked by the Board of Supervisors to review the candidates for the seat after the Newhall Water District board was unable to select an applicant within the required 60-day period. Noyes has recommended that Thomas be appointed because she was a former member and had run for the position in the last election.
“Based on our review of the eight candidates’ applications, we found all of them to be qualified to be a member of the district board. However, in our opinion, we found ... Thomas to be the best qualified candidate to fill the vacancy,” Noyes wrote to the Board of Supervisors Aug. 8.
Supervisor Michael D. Antonovich, who represents the Santa Clarita Valley, said he is still considering the Public Works Department’s recommendation to appoint Thomas to replace member Dick Unger, who moved out of the area.
“We will know more on Tuesday,” said Tony Bell, a spokesman for Antonovich. “He is currently considering whether or not to take the recommendation under consideration and will make a decision on Tuesday.”
Newhall Water District board member Lynne Plambeck said Friday she is disappointed that members Barbara Dore and Randall Pfiester refused to compromise on their support of Thomas, which resulted in the appointment decision being sent to the Board of Supervisors.
“They just let the time expire and didn’t show up to meetings or make a compromise so that Antonovich would appoint her,” Plambeck said.
She said Dore and Pfiester didn’t attend board meetings on July 23 and 25 to appoint a candidate.
Dore couldn’t be reached for comment Friday.
“There were five candidates and we (Plambeck and member Joan Dunn) would have accepted any one except Valerie Thomas,” Plambeck said. “She was voted out of office.
“This is a game that is being played to appoint Val Thomas. Antonovich didn’t want to directly appoint her, so he told public works to appoint her. We should have at least had a special election,” she said.
Thomas said she was pleased by the Public Works Department recommendation, but disappointed that the Newhall Water District board is so divided. She said that, if she is appointed to the five-member board, she will bring a definite point of view to the board.
“I am concerned about water in all of its aspects, as far as it affects the community,” Thomas said. “I’m not interested in creating any more antagonism than has to be there.”
Plambeck said, “Val will toe the party line. She will not say anything about what is really going on with the water in the valley.”
During the four years Thomas was a member of the board, she said, the Newhall County Water District was able to establish a business-like relationship with the area, borrow money at a better interest rate, improve its facilities, improve communication between itself and other water districts and the downstream water users in Ventura County; and establish procedures to ensure standards.
