Despite protests from some of its neighbors about zoning, traffic and safety issues, the Carousel Ranch therapeutic horseriding program can continue to operate in Sand Canyon until October.
Santa Clarita City Council members voted 3-1 Tuesday in favor of allowing the non-profit program to operate on Ravenhill Road but prohibited riders from straying outside the property’s boundaries.
“I’m happy with the results tonight,” said Denise Tomey, a director and co-founder of the program. “(But) I question the precedent that it’s setting.”
Residents’ children often ride along the private road, and children who live nearby and patrons of a nearby commercial boarding stable may also ride their horses on the road, she said.
Carousel Ranch operates a four-day-a-week horse riding therapy program for disabled children and adults.
While Mayor Cameron Smyth cast the lone dissenting vote against extending Carousel Ranch’s permit, it was not against the program. The vote was against the conditions of the permit.
“I didn’t think we could single out one group of people (to) restrict their use,” Smyth said after the meeting. “I support Carousel Ranch. The motion is too restrictive to the ridership.”
While the program will be allowed to remain in Sand Canyon for the time being, its offer on a 13-acre piece of property in Canyon Country has been accepted and escrow has begun. Tomey said she hopes to relocate before October. Councilman Bob Kellar orchestrated the transaction.
The Canyon Country property, up Sierra Highway about two miles past Vasquez Canyon, was found by Kellar, who co-owns Kellar-Davis Real Estate. Kellar also resides on Ravenhill Road. He has said he would not make a profit on the transaction and recused himself from the vote to avoid any appearance of a conflict of interest.
“If something comes to fruition, anything I’d be making would be donated back to Carousel,” he said earlier.
The former mayor said he feels strong support for the program and sees it as a welcome addition to his street, but acknowledged the sentiment is not universal among his neighbors.
On Oct. 19, the Planning Commission voted 4-1 to extend the program’s temporary use permit for a second year, through Oct. 21, 2005. Following the commission’s vote, 16 residents on Ravenhill Road in Sand Canyon appealed the decision to the City Council.
Planning Commissioner Diane Trautman reaffirmed the commission’s decision before the council members.
Several speakers pleaded their case with council members. A city planner refuted neighbors’ complaints about negative impacts.
While the disputed issues are longstanding, a question of serious personal liability for property owners on the private road rose to the fore.
Resident Jack Cole said neighbors have been tolerant, but it was “very arrogant on their part” to bring a commercial operation into a residential neighborhood. He called for restrictions on the permit if the October deadline held fast.
Tomey countered that if restrictions for riding horses on Ravenhill were imposed, they should apply to everyone.
Students generally ride the specially-trained slow-ambling horses around an arena, but they are rewarded for hard work with a ride along Ravenhill Road in the rural community.
Councilwoman Marsha McLean questioned the fairness of imposing restrictions on some children who ride horses on the road, but not on others.
City Attorney Carl Newton opined on restricting the use of a private road for a business operation and on lawsuits that could result from personal injury.
“All neighbors run the risk,” he said. “(Injured parties) will sue whoever maintains the road.”
Businessman Wayne Crawford, a Ravenhill Road resident, downplayed the liability issue.
“Let Wayne indemnify us all!” someone shouted from the audience.
Councilwoman Laurene Weste said “We want to make everyone happy,” acknowledging it would be a tall order.
The compromise mandates the Oct. 21, 2005, deadline and prohibits students from riding outside the ranch’s boundaries — to ensure what was deemed a safer environment for all.
