Santa Clarita is putting teeth in its sign ordinance, and business and property owners who violate the law may soon feel the bite.
About 60 businesses continue to display signs that do not conform with the law, and after a nine-year grace period, the signs’ days may be numbered.
The signs could be yanked down.
“It’s not fair to the people who have adhered to the law” not to enforce the sign ordinance, said City Manager Ken Pulskamp at a Santa Clarita City Council-Planning Commission study session Tuesday. “We tried hard to take the carrot approach. It didn’t work.”
The law, intended to beautify the roadways, was adopted in 1990. A majority — 97 percent — of the 2,400 sign-bearing businesses have complied with city rules.
The ordinance regulates the full range of sign types and provides development standards for the type of sign based on the size and location of the property, Planning Manager Lisa Hardy said Thursday. Sign types include monument, freeway-oriented, temporary, storefront, directional and banners.
While local governments have the power to regulate on-premise signs, signage is protected by the First Amendment, according to Jason Mikaelian, an associate planner for the city.
Staff from the planning and building departments, community preservation and the city attorney’s office will pool their resources to address the problem.
“We would like to think of removing the sign as a last resort,” Mikaelian said. “Signing is a passionate topic. It identifies a community and it also identifies businesses. You do have to have a balance between the two.”
Uniform requirements establish a level playing field with businesses, he said.
Businesses in other communities have stood their ground and successfully filed suit against cities, alleging sign ordinances violated the state’s business and professional code by failing to account for extenuating circumstances.
A local business could take that route.
In April, the council denied a variance for the Santa Clarita Athletic Club sign near Interstate 5, despite suggestions by an attorney for the club that the case would wind up in court.
The club’s sign predates the city’s 1987 incorporation, having been used by the property’s previous owner, an auto dealership. It is oversized and includes flashing lights to display messages to motorists.
A plan suggested by city staff would have allowed the business to keep the lights if it agreed to lower the height of the sign and redesign it. The attorney said that could cost more than $300,000. A different plan for revamping the sign proposed by owner Charles Hamilton could cost about $140,000. Hamilton has not complied with the city’s findings.
In August, Hamilton gave the sign a “face-lift” that cost almost $20,000, said Laura Edwards, the club’s general manager. A survey of members indicated the sign contributed significantly to the club’s visibility and enrollment, she said. And the sign has been used as a notification tool during disaster situations, she added.
“We did want to fix the sign and comply with the (city’s) request, but they didn’t want it the way we wanted it,” Hamilton said. “It had to be their way or no way.”
Mikaelian said the club’s sign is on the nonconforming list.
The city plans to deal with the offending signs in phases, largely for logistical reasons — first in Canyon Country, then in Saugus and Valencia, and finally in Newhall. Improvements under way on Bouquet Junction, and the specific plan in the works for Downtown Newhall pushed those communities further down on the list.
The “displeasing” signs are often concentrated on busy roadways.
In Canyon Country, Soledad Canyon Road and Sierra Highway had the greatest number of nonconforming signs; in the Saugus and Valencia areas, Soledad and Bouquet topped the list. In Newhall, the Lyons Avenue corridor tallied the most offenders.
A systematic process will be followed before the city steps in to remove any signs. A 30-day notice will be sent to property owners, which will result in one of three outcomes: Owners may remove the signs voluntarily. They may appeal the decision to the planning commission and if they are denied there, they may file an appeal with the City Council. If property owners ignore the notice, city staff members will send a notice to the council, requesting that the council declare the sign a nuisance.
If a resolution is adopted approving the removal, the city would give the owner a deadline. If the owner fails to comply, the council could obtain a court order and hire a contractor to remove the sign. This can be a costly option, as large freestanding signs could cost more than $20,000 to remove, Mikaelian said.
City staff members would place a notice on the sign and on the property noting when the sign would be removed.
Property owners would find the city’s outlay for the removal added to their tax bill. The county would later reimburse the city.
Councilman Bob Kellar endorsed the crackdown.
“Where signs are replaced enhances the city,” he said. “It is not a negative at all.”
