A San Francisco judge’s ruling in favor of gay marriage is sure to be appealed, Santa Clarita Mayor Cameron Smyth said Monday, while a proponent of same-sex unions said the decision is an occasion to rejoice.
“Today I was offered hope and promise that one day I will be able to get married,” said Eddie Gutierrez, communications director for Equality California, a statewide advocacy organization for gay and lesbian rights. “It’s powerful to have the legal system affirm that my relationship is valid.”
“This is an example of the frustration Americans have with activist judges,” said Smyth, former aide to state Sen. William J. “Pete” Knight, R-Palmdale. Knight sponsored Proposition 22, approved by California voters in 2000, which defined marriage as a union between one man and one woman.
“Sixty percent of Californians approved Proposition 22,” Smyth said, which “shows a majority of Californians support traditional marriage.”
“Obviously, the ruling’s going to get appealed, another step in the long battle to protect traditional marriage,” the mayor said.
Smyth added that his opposition to gay marriage “doesn’t mean I don’t respect the relationship that homosexuals have, or don’t respect the quality of their relationship.”
Gutierrez and his partner, whose relationship has spanned almost nine years, are registered as domestic partners.
The couple is barred from enjoying the economic advantages of marriage afforded to heterosexual couples. The distinction was amplified this weekend when they prepared their tax forms, unable to file a joint return, Gutierrez said.
He added that while his partner has considered buying a home, no tax benefit would accrue for the couple. The write-offs could only be claimed by his partner.
On the day their civil marriage ceremony was planned, the pair got word the California Supreme Court had invalidated nearly 4,000 same-sex marriage licenses issued in the city of San Francisco.
“That was a heartfelt and exceedingly difficult day,” he said.
Today’s decision gave Gutierrez and his partner, who is 28, hope.
“We were thinking (we’d be) 50, 60 before we got that shot (to marry),” he said. “We have similar qualities, we’re just like everyone else. (Marriage) is about love. A marriage license is a living, breathing document. We would like to have the opportunity to have that document.
“(The decision) affirms my relationship is recognized,” he said. “There will be a day when the state recognizes my relationship fully and equally under the law.”
