Lynne Plambeck shirked her fiduciary duty to the taxpayers.
That, simply, is why this newspaper called for her resignation from the Newhall County Water District board of directors.
It’s not about whether Plambeck is right to believe contaminated water shouldn’t count as “available” water supply. It’s not about growth. It’s not about any basic philosophical disagreements with Plambeck.
It’s about crossing the line.
I happen to respect Lynne Plambeck in certain ways. I admire her passion for her cause, and I find her to be an intelligent advocate for it. I just happen to be on the other side of the issues from her, most of the time — and that’s OK.
But her actions were unconscionable in the legal dispute over the local water utilities’ Urban Water Management Plan. In the case, the Friends of the Santa Clara River and the Sierra Club successfully challenged the water plan. As our editorial noted, the case is essentially moot because the plan expires this year anyway, and a new one is being drawn up that addresses the issues raised in the lawsuit.
Plambeck wants you to pay the attorneys who represented her friends in the lawsuit.
In a signed declaration, Plambeck provided arguments as to why the court should force the water purveyors — including the Newhall County Water District — to pay the plaintiffs’ attorney fees.
After our editorial was published calling for her to step down, Plambeck told The Signal it was at least partially a misunderstanding.
Plambeck, cooperating with the Friends’ and Sierra Club’s attorneys, signed a declaration stating her beliefs that the case was important to water planning issues in California. The reason the attorneys would want such a declaration from her? Think dollar signs.
Plambeck now claims she never saw the title of the declaration: “Reply declaration of Lynne Plambeck in support of petitioners’ motion for attorneys’ fees.”
Even if she didn’t see the title — even if she just signed on the bottom line without reviewing her statement to the court in its final, typewritten form — she was helping the plaintiffs in their effort to force you, the taxpayer, to foot the bill for the environmental groups’ legal challenge.
Toss aside the water issues for now. This isn’t about water.
When you are elected to represent the public’s best interest, as Plambeck was, you accept a duty to protect the taxpayers’ interests — and wallets.
For the most part, I think Plambeck and others who share her political beliefs are attempting to abuse water planning issues in an effort to control growth. But that, again, is not the point.
And, even if you think the water agencies SHOULD pay the fees, that also is not the point.
The point is, when Plambeck asked the court to force the water utilities to spend more than $200,000 of your money on the attorney fees for a lawsuit against those water utilities — including the one for which she is a board member — she stopped being an advocate of the water district’s interests.
She can agree with the plaintiffs all she wants. She can believe the case was important. She can cast dissenting votes when the board decides whether to defend against a legal claim or roll over. She can voice her opinion on the issues until the Santa Clarita Valley’s last few remaining cows come home.
But what she did amounts to sabotage. Sleeping with the enemy.
That’s why she should resign. But she won’t. Instead, this issue will get turned around by those who agree with her on the water issues. We’ve already gotten a couple of letters to the editor from environmental activists, and they’re focusing on Plambeck’s positions on the Urban Water Management Plan.
Once more, with feeling: That is SO not the point.
Whether you agree with her or disagree with her on water issues, this isn’t about water. It’s about money. Taxpayers’ money. It’s about a public official’s fiduciary duty to act in the best interests of the agency she represents.
No one can argue that it’s in the agency’s best interest to advocate paying a legal foe’s expenses. Regardless of whether the case was won or lost, justified or frivolous, it’s Plambeck’s job to protect the water district’s interests, financial and otherwise.
Asking the court to take away the agency’s money is no way to do that.
Tim Whyte is The Signal’s general manager. His column regularly appears Sundays in the opinion section and Tuesdays on page A2. He can be reached by calling 259-1234, ext. 234, and his e-mail address is [email protected].
