Stay in the unincorporated county and you’ll never get to vote for four of the five people who run your local government.
Stay in the unincorporated county and you get a Board of Supervisors that approves a 78-million-ton sand and gravel mine in your valley.
Stay in the unincorporated county and you can worry that your parks will close every time there’s a budgetary hiccup.
Stay in the unincorporated county and you get two sheriff’s deputies to patrol hundreds of square miles, versus 15 per shift in the 50-square-mile city of Santa Clarita.
Stay in the unincorporated county and you can hear government officials low-ball local growth projections after their boss signed off on a transportation plan that’s designed to accommodate hundreds of thousands of new homes in the north county.
Stay in the unincorporated county and you get to pay an extra 5-percent tax just to turn on the lights.
What? Those things weren’t in the brochure?
Go figure.
Two weeks ago, the county of Los Angeles distributed a slick, full-color brochure to the SCV’s west-side residents telling them, “You have choices for local government.”
Masquerading as an informational piece, it gives the illusion that staying in the unincorporated county is just as good if not better than annexing to the city of Santa Clarita. (It even suggests that forming a second city is a viable option “now or at a future date” — even though state law forbids it until such time as the west side has a big enough industrial base to pay for municipal services. That’s decades away.)
With the intonation, “Make sure you have full and accurate information to exercise your rights,” it’s the most disingenuous thing we’ve seen emerge from the bowels of Supervisor Mike Antonovich’s office in a long time.
When it says there are “few, if any, direct financial advantages” to staying in the county, joining the city or creating a new city, it insults the intelligence of every west-sider — and every city resident who’s seen it.
Right off the bat, forming a new city would require massive new taxes because the state no longer gives the full vehicle license fee to new cities.
More on point, it’s not rocket science to know you’re better off financially, and in many other ways, by being in the city.
Maybe Antonovich thinks that after 17 years of cityhood we’ve all gone senile, but up until 18 years ago the entire Santa Clarita Valley was in the unincorporated county. Even then, we didn’t want to be part of Los Angeles County. A decade earlier, in the mid-1970s, vast majorities of SCV voters opted to form their own county.
But the vote required the assent of the rest of Los Angeles County, which even then wanted to keep us. Why? Because the property taxpayers of the SCV were sending millions of dollars more every year to downtown Los Angeles than they were getting back in services. We were a cash cow.
State laws changed in the late 1970s and it became virtually impossible to form a new county, so in 1987 we pursued the only breakaway option that didn’t require the consent of the rest of the county: city formation.
Then, as in the 1970s, a big reason for seizing local control was to capture the millions of dollars that weren’t coming back. Now, the local share of our property taxes would truly stay local. They’d be controlled by people from our own community whom we elected to serve on our own City Council.
Antonovich’s brochure states, “basic property taxes do not change subsequent to annexation.” That’s misleading, at best. No, the dollar amount doesn’t change. But today’s west-siders are in the same property-tax boat that the rest of Santa Clarita was in prior to cityhood.
Today, west-siders send their local share of the property tax to downtown Los Angeles, never to see much of it again after the three-member majority of Gloria Molina, Yvonne Burke and Zev Yaroslavsky get done spending it. Today, west-siders are the county’s cash cow.
Antonovich’s brochure states that one “consideration in evaluating your options” is that the character of the west-side communities “may or may not” be consistent with Santa Clarita.
Hello? Santa Clarita is the sum of its parts. Folks in Canyon Country don’t share all of the same values and interests as folks in Valencia. And yet, Santa Clarita accommodates and celebrates both. The west side won’t change in character if its seat of government switches from downtown Los Angeles to Valencia Boulevard. Rather, it’s the other way around. Santa Clarita will adapt and change as new areas are added. In truth, the character of the west side is far more closely aligned to that of Santa Clarita than, say, Lennox or Littlerock.
From the get-go, city creators wanted to include the entire SCV in their new city of Santa Clarita. Their efforts were dashed for two reasons. One, the big developers who still had lots of raw land had a good deal with the county. The supervisors let them plunder our valley virtually at will, without being forced to pay for enough roads, schools and parks. They petitioned to stay outside the new city.
The county was only too happy to let them stay outside the city, and that’s reason No. 2. The county knew the Interstate 5 corridor from Stevenson Ranch to Castaic was poised for explosive growth, and it wanted to hang on to all the property-tax dollars it could.
Bottom line? Join the city and you get to elect all five of your local decision-makers. Join the city and you escape the 5-percent utility users tax. Join the city and you get a higher level of police service for the same amount of money. Join the city and you get to use all of the city’s parks.
Oh, wait. The city already allows west-siders to use its parks, out of consideration for the fact that unincorporated residents pay the county for parks and recreation programs but don’t get as much as city residents do for the same money.
Don’t expect to read about that in a county brochure.
