For some people, the prospect of a second open-pit mine up Soledad Canyon is an outrage.
For John Heter, it’s a dream come true.
“I had my heart and soul in this project,” Heter said at a recent Agua Dulce Town Council meeting.
Heter was co-owner of Industrial Mineral Fillers, which officials say ran the Caspar Mine on Soledad Canyon Road about five miles east of state Route 14 since the 1950s.
When the firm went bankrupt and the mine shut down in 2000, Heter told the Agua Dulce Town Council last week, he formed a new firm called Pacific Industrial Minerals and began developing a proposal to reopen the Caspar Mine, located on U.S. Forest Service property.
He said he took out a lease in 2003 and developed a proposal to reopen the mine.
The revelation earlier this month that a second open-pit mine was proposed in Soledad Canyon, practically across the street from the site of the proposed Cemex mine, outraged many officials with the city of Santa Clarita, who have long battled the federal and county government over the Cemex proposal.
Heter told the Agua Dulce Town Council that he took community ignorance of the mine as a compliment.
“We weren’t causing any problems,” he said. “No one complained, (and) that’s the way it’s supposed to be.”
Town Council President Andy Fried said the advisory body hasn’t taken a stand on the mine proposal.
Both the Cemex and the Pacific Industrial plans call for 20 years of mining.
The Caspar Mine would extract 150,000 tons of anorthosite per year, crush it on site and transport it by truck across Soledad Canyon Road to SR-14. Pacific Industrial would also have to rebuild a bridge across the Santa Clara River that was washed out during last winter’s rains.
The Cemex mine would remove 78 million tons of sand and gravel from that location over the course of the 20 years. It, too, would result in trucked material on SR-14.
Extensive truck traffic, air pollution and quality-of-life issues all have been cited by Santa Clarita officials as reasons why the Cemex mine should not be permitted by the Bureau of Land Management.
The U.S. Forest Service’s handling of the plan to reopen the Caspar Mine has come under fire, especially from Rep. Howard “Buck” McKeon, since the plan was revealed.
“The U.S. Forest Service was in abject failure,” said Scott Wilk, McKeon’s district director.
According to Wilk, the Forest Service has not explained to the satisfaction of residents why the project was in development for five years before the city was notified. He said public furor over the Cemex project makes this especially problematical.
Sherry Rollman, a Forest Service spokeswoman, said the federal agency reviewed several proposed plans for the mining project beginning in 2002, repeatedly returning them to Pacific Industrial for clarification. A completed proposal was submitted at the end of last year, she said.
Rollman said it is typical for the proposal review process to last several months, which is why notification of the mining plan was not even released until several months after the final proposal had been submitted.
She said Santa Clarita officials were not notified of a new mining proposal until now because the Forest Service cannot release notifications until a completed plan of operations has been received.
The initial fax that city officials received earlier this month did not necessarily clear things up. Rather than an official Forest Service letterhead, the notice was sent on a plain sheet of paper, prompting officials to question its validity.
Furthermore, the fax listed a public comment period ending May 17, giving residents less than two weeks for input, far less time than the standard 30 days.
McKeon’s office pressured the Forest Service over the public-comment period, and the agency relented.
In a press release sent out last week, this time on Forest Service letterhead, the public-comment period was extended to June 13.
At Wednesday’s Agua Dulce Town Council meeting, Forest Service spokeswoman Cid Morgan said the agency is working to schedule a public scoping meeting, likely at the end of this month.
Morgan saw a silver lining in the Forest Service’s oversight.
“I’m very happy this miscommunication happened,” she said, “because it has brought attention to the notification process.”
