The practitioner in me is aghast. The rest of me is indignant. I guess I just can’t believe what I am witnessing.
On Saturday, The Signal covered the lawsuit filed by attorney Gloria Allred on behalf of four plaintiffs, all of whom allege deliberate indifference to purported racial hostility on campus.
Allred likens the suit to the landmark case of Brown v. Board of Education, stating that it is “Round 2 in the fight for equal education.”
What comes next is the professional equivalent of a barroom brawl.
However, with respect to rules of ethics, I promise to be a gentleman in commenting about a fellow member of the California State Bar.
So, putting it politely: Equating the suit against the school board to Brown v. Board of Education is the single most misguided and misinformed statement I have ever heard come out of a lawyer’s mouth.
Further, leading these young litigants down the slippery slope of racist accusations is ethically akin to doing Michael Jackson’s next nose job.
As a sampler of how exhausted these claims have been, I invite the public to visit the following Web site: http://caag.state.ca.us/publications/civilrights/01CRhandbook/chapter6.htm .
The site sets forth a mere synopsis of the California Education Code provisions for protecting against discrimination in the educational setting. In addition to the California Education Code, there exists the United States Education Act (Title IX) on which to base a claim of discrimination.
Matters of civil rights and discrimination have been so thoroughly litigated that the one-paragraph case summaries take up more than an entire volume of the annotated United States Codes.
Simply, the legal schemes for presenting a discrimination-based lawsuit are numerous, comprehensive and complex.
Round 2? It appears that someone has not done her homework.
As a practitioner, I advise more people not to sue than I advise to undertake suit. It’s a simple fact of life: There is not a legal remedy for everything.
Further, if you want to go out and sue, you had better be prepared to answer the tough questions about the basis for legal responsibility and substantiating your damages. Undertaking a legal pleading and alleging that a person is a racist, or officially indifferent to racism, is very serious business.
But more troubling is leading people — young people — into litigation without doing the homework.
There is a special way to handle the claims of young litigants. I have represented kids (anyone under 22, in my book) in everything from murder cases to drug trafficking to trivial matters. Young people, being pumped with idealism, have a certain view as to how the system is going to treat them. They are frequently wrong.
A brief war story is warranted. To this day, I shudder when I think about a case I handled in New York. At the time, it was the largest single-defendant Ecstacy case out of Kennedy International Airport.
My client, a 19-year-old kid, was facing 10 years in federal prison after getting caught by U.S. Customs with 30 pounds of Ecstasy.
He protested his innocence and I let him push me around. We went all the way to jury selection before I was able to knock some sense into him.
Thankfully, he took a deal and was awarded probation. But had I not taken that horse by the reins, he would certainly have been convicted and sentenced to a lengthy federal commitment.
In his mind, he was, and will always be, innocent. But I guarantee you that the system would not have seen it that way.
The moral of the story is simple. When you deal with young people, it is wrong to leave the idealism unchecked. And it is immoral to play upon it.
Now that everyone has had his nose thoroughly rubbed in accusations of racism, I am sure they will be that much more open to dialogue. Right? Indeed, it is the acts of the gadfly that cause us to avoid our neighbors, avoid dialogue and refuse to let people into our house for fear of being sued after they trip over the carpet.
This misguided lawsuit has done nothing but compound the issue of race relations.
In fact, proverbially speaking, if someone gets the electric chair when this is all over, the parents of the suitors and any racist antagonists deserve 50 percent of the voltage.
In the meantime, someone will be making a name for herself.
Anthony D. Zinnanti is a Valencia attorney who lives in Saugus. His column represents his own views, and not necessarily those of The Signal.
