Editor:
I was looking at the bald eagle on the front page of your newspaper. It is holding “Vigilance Forever” on a banner in its beak. It holds arrows in its right talon and an olive branch in its left talon. The eagle is turned to face the arrows.
This is in reverse from the bald eagle on the back of a $1 bill. On the bill, the eagle holds the olive branch in its right talon and the arrows are in its left talon. The eagle faces the olive branch, showing favor to peace. “E pluribus unum” is the motto in the beak, which means that there are many states that are united into one country. Is there a significance in the different eagle that you print?
Andrew Hild (age 10)
Santa Clarita
Great question, Andrew. You’re right: The Signal eagle is different from the Great Seal of the United States, which appears on the back of the $1 bill.
On the original Great Seal, designed by a committee of Benjamin Franklin, John Adams and Thomas Jefferson in 1776 and adopted by Congress in 1782, the eagle faces the olive branch, which is in its right talon (to the viewer’s left). The idea was to show that the United States prefers peace but that it’s willing to defend itself, as symbolized by the 13 arrows (for the original 13 colonies) in the eagle’s left talon.
In heraldry, the left side is known as the “sinister” side (it doesn’t mean evil) and the right side is the “dexter” side. According to the Act of Congress of June 20, 1782, the eagle in the official seal holds “in its dexter talon an olive branch, and in his sinister a bundle of 13 arrows. ... The olive branch and arrows denote the power of peace and war which is exclusively vested in Congress.”
In various applications over the years, the arrows and olive branches switched places. For instance, when a version of the heraldic eagle (with “E pluribus unum,” or “Out of many, one”) first appeared on U.S. coins in 1797, the arrows were in the right talon. Some people think this was a mistake on the part of coin designer Robert Scot; others think he purposefully intended to show that the United States was prepared for war if England attacked.
The arrows were moved to the left talon, their normal position, starting with the coins of 1807. In retrospect, moving them was probably a bad idea. War came in 1812 and British troops burned the White House in 1814.
Lyndon Johnson was in the White House 150 years later when the “Signal eagle” debuted on the masthead of The Newhall Signal and Saugus Enterprise, as it was called.
John F. Kennedy had died a month and a half earlier and patriotism was running high. In Washington, Congress hastily ordered the replacement of the old Ben Franklin half dollar (with the Liberty Bell on the back) with Gilroy Roberts’ portrait of the assassinated president and, on the back, Frank Gasparro’s engraving of the presidential coat of arms, which is very similar to the Great Seal.
The same month the nation lost a president, the Santa Clarita Valley gained a swashbuckling pirate of an editor (to borrow John Boston’s vernacular). He was Scott Newhall, great-grandson of town founder Henry Mayo Newhall, and veteran of The Chronicle in San Francisco, where the Newhall descendant beat rival William Randolph Hearst’s Examiner in the circulation game.
Scott Newhall turned this paper — and this town — on its ear with his fiery prose. The Jan. 9, 1964, edition of The Signal was a portent of things to come. That’s when Newhall took The Signal through a major redesign, changing not only the masthead but also the typeface to make the paper more readable, and improving the placement of news stories and opinion pieces.
His predecessor’s masthead depicted a more bucolic SCV with a bluish-green drawing of mountains behind an oil derrick and a corral with cattle, sheep and a tractor.
Scott Newhall’s Signal would be anything but bucolic. The Signal — which was published only on Thursdays — issued an explanatory warning a week before making the change.
On Jan. 2, a full-page ad with the headline, “A New Year, A New Look,” above the new eagle said, “The American eagle, traditional symbol of fierceness, freedom and individuality, signals a new era for readers of The Signal. Watch your doorstep next Thursday for a new look version of your favorite newspaper.”
Yes, “new look version.” Oh, well.
In the second edition of the redesigned Signal, on Jan. 16, readers reacted favorably to the changes — although they weren’t too sure about a new feature called, “The Question Man.” It was the 1960s version of the current “Signal on the Street” interview. The inaugural question was, “What’s wrong with Newhall women?” Seven guys were dumb enough to answer. The smarter ones said, “nothing.” Others said Newhall’s women were “stuck up,” “too nosy,” and “won’t talk to you unless you have a new car.”
I think I’ve strayed from Andrew’s question. Sorry.
The Signal eagle isn’t the eagle of the Great Seal or the presidential seal. It’s clutching four arrows, not 13, and its banner reads, “Vigilance forever” — which we like to think is self-explanatory — not, “E pluribus unum.”
All of this is a long-winded way of saying I don’t know why Scott Newhall selected this particular eagle. I can’t ask him; he died in 1992. I failed to reach two of his three sons Tuesday — Skip of Santa Clarita and Jon of Oakland. (Son Tony is in China, visiting his daughter. I didn’t call).
If any old Signalites can shed some light, please drop us a line.
For more about the Kennedy half dollar, read Dr. Sol Taylor’s coin column in Saturday’s Business section. Leon Worden is The Signal’s opinion and multimedia editor.
